You're a Liar

Discussion in 'Trading' started by ElectricSavant, Nov 1, 2018.

  1. Turveyd

    Turveyd

    Forex brokers aren't that bad, although I've heard of a few that refuse to pay out profits made and just close the account and ignore the client.
     
    #31     Nov 2, 2018
  2. I stopped day trading and started swing trading. Mathematically there is more noise in daybrading which results in more noise (randomness).
    Swing trading however has more predictability.
    To make a living swing trading single leg directional futures/Forex you need a huge account.
    Or you could structure trades using option spreads to create predictable income with low margin on a smaller account.
    Really all you need to do is reverse engineer the math to find out if you can pay your bills through trading.
    Formula for expectation of profit is one I refer to a lot when deciding what trades to take.
    Also markets are priced in. You really need to have advanced knowledge or make predictions based on quantifiable data to make any $$$.
    This is why I don’t trust 99% of the unsophisticated traders out there trying to say they are profitable. You are competing with some of the brightest and well informed traders on Wall Street; what makes you think you can beat them with your retail platform and retail tools??? Curious to know.
     
    #32     Nov 3, 2018
  3. Exactly. This Oct has been one of my best months ever, without which I would have only done ok this year, nothing fantastic, probably a little over 10%.
     
    #33     Nov 3, 2018
    trader99 likes this.
  4. Nimbleness. We can move retail sizes of few hundred K or M easily. Easy fills, minimal slippage. Big money don't have this luxury. Massive advantage.

    As for using retail platforms/tools - price is price. We get the same price data, which is what we are trading, as the pros. Besides HFT, I do not see the advantage in fancier platforms.
     
    #34     Nov 3, 2018
    qlai and rb7 like this.
  5. What a idiotic thing too say that all retail traders trading forex is loosing.....Why doo you think Forex have trillions of dollars shifting hands everyday because everybody is loosing???because you cant doo it doesnt mean everybody is loosers....
     
    #35     Nov 3, 2018
  6. SteveH

    SteveH

    OP, I told you and everyone else on ET how to be a winning intraday futures trader.

    Not my fault that your ego won't listen and learn from someone who knows what you seek.
     
    #36     Nov 3, 2018
  7. MarkBrown

    MarkBrown

    so you going to help the guy out or just flap jaw?
     
    #37     Nov 3, 2018
    legionx likes this.
  8. I am just a wannabe crude oil trader (trading simulated right now) and you appear to be right on. Thursday, Oil when down $2.00 in 50 minutes. That is a $2,000 gain and if you could just average $2,000 per month per contract in oil you are a successful trader. I only got a fraction of that gain ($450 on the day) but Friday lost over $900 so I have a ways to go.

    The reverse question is "Why is it so easy to lose" You don't even have to try. I marvel about just how easy it is. It is sooo easy to pick intraday tops and bottoms when you are on the wrong side. I just keep plugging because if it is that easy to lose then how hard can it be to win? It seems like I just need to engineer my brain to think in reverse.
     
    #38     Nov 3, 2018
  9. just stay away from the 5 min crap
     
    #39     Nov 3, 2018
    comagnum likes this.
  10. A thought we've all had at one time or another.
     
    #40     Nov 3, 2018