YM Traders

But that doesn't explain those traders that don't have a "system" or "set of rules"

Are those traders just doomed for failure.

I don't see how anyone has the authority to define what an idea is, knowing that an "edge" can mean many many many things, and can apply to any type of trader.

I just don't believe in the idea of an "edge"



Here is another question. Are all traders with an "edge" successful. Because from some threads I get the idea that all traders with an "edge" are consistantly profitable, which is again why I asked, is an "edge" another saying for just being "consistantly profitable"?

I just don't believe in an "edge", just as I don't believe in luck.


Or am I one of those people who think "outside of the box"

But yet, if I don't believe in an edge, how could I be successful, and how come a lot of people say in order to be successful, you must think outside of the box?

It just doesn't make sense to me.




*again, just trying to get peoples opinions on this...... not trying to actually argue anything, just friendly chatter*

 

So, JM my honest offer to help you was rejected because u r here while u r waiting to start trading, and need nothing more to be successful? In other words, you have learned all u need to know to be successful in this business.....did I read that post correctly.?.

 

Let's talk this stuff tonight JM withoout getting mad and bailing out......we all love the business i hope....not just the allure of big money........

 

Bailing out, getting mad, and allure of big money.

Who mentioned anything about big money?

Wow porgie, once again, you have just gone out of this world and pulling out stuff.

Lets just quit before you confuse me any more.

Once again, you can not handle discussion. So, don't comment on it. I actually attending a college class on discussion and arguments, mainly being the focus. So, I just don't get how you make out some of the stuff you say.



I'm just trying to see what Volente believes on this whole thing about an "edge", nothing more, nothing less. I don't need help, because all the help I'm going to recieve from now on is going to be from my mentor, or from personal experience in trading myself, which is how I believe I can learn it best.

End of that discussion.

*And blocked before it progresses anymore than this point*

 

Okay JM............I came here confused....ask me any question about trading the emini's and I will give a straight answer right her and now.........except what my system is.....

 

vol, did i say the wrong thing? Just trying to help a young trader...I guess he has allthe answers he wants or needs....I wish I cdould have learned it all that f ast......

 

I bet JM is at the head of that "argument and discussion class"...........I still think vol is his mentor.......

 

JM now that u have cooled off, ask me any question u wish about emini trading and I will give the best answer known to man......

 

porgie honestly i've seen you're babbling notes for 3 months AND I CAN'T RECALL ONE TIME YOU MENTIONED HOW YOU TRADE OR IF YOU EVEN TRADE. YOU BABBLE ABOUT A SYSTEM BUT HAVE SHOWN NO PROVE OF ANYTHING. please correct me if i'm wrong.

 

Never forget, thinking outside the box only helps if you are outside the correct box.don't get too far away from the correct box......there are many boxes.......dumb is muc h better........no thinking allowed.......after the battle is won.......