Will you stay with Cyber/Schwab if they only offer per trade pricing?

Discussion in 'Retail Brokers' started by Chetnik, Apr 25, 2007.

  1. I am narrowing down my list of brokers. One that seems really interesting is TradeKing.com. Take their tour. Plenty of trading tools. and some of the best prices I have seen.
    Pricing is secondary to me. I will call on Monday. I have plenty of questions.
    One thing they definetly have over CT is their cash and buying power balances, immediately updated in real time

    As far as Java based programs being slow, every demo I downloaded that was java based was extremely slow. I agree, stay away.
     
    #341     Dec 15, 2007
  2. buybig

    buybig

    wow, when if first started trading i was long a position that was in a downward sprial. so to hedge the position I went short the same stock x shares.

    F**ucked their software up. had to call in b/c i couldnt close. their moronic (in retrospec) broker says i went short against the box?:confused:
     
    #342     Dec 15, 2007
  3. Funny that you ask...I noticed the same thing late yesterday. I'll inquire Monday morning and post my results.

    I'm leaning towards Noble. They have bent over backwards working with me, making sure their software is comparable to my needs. Their pricing is better than what I was getting at Schwab, so this may turn out to be a blessing in disguise.

    Again, I average about 10 days trades per day, all equities, with sometimes high volume (minimum 5,000 shares...sometimes as high as 20,000 shares per trade). Sometimes it's better to work with smaller companies as they will be bend over backwards for your business.
     
    #343     Dec 15, 2007
  4. One thing I like about Schwab is the fact that they will be there monday morning. I'm sure brokers like those some of you are looking at offer good deals, but what about the trust factor? Do you really trust your funds with them? I understand the funds are held at a clearing agent like Penson, but the broker has all your info and I have to wonder how secure it is. Plus, it's not clear to me what happens if they go belly up.

    Now what troubles me about Schwab is they don't have the same sort of apparently iron-clad fraud gaurantee that ETrade for example offers. Of course, that guarantee is not worth much if ETrade goes bankrupt.
     
    #344     Dec 15, 2007
  5. richk

    richk


    Hi ,
    I am sure you can receive nice individual fee offer from Pinnacle (my broker). They are really friendly and good company. Penson based accounts, direct access software (Level II) and so. And they are in business for several years.
    Ask them for individual offer - it is my recommendation.
     
    #345     Dec 16, 2007
  6. Richard...Richard Koza, right? This is the third or fourth time you've tried to sell this broker to me. Is this a pyramid type scam or what? Either way, I'm not interested, so please discontinue me from your ad campaign!
     
    #346     Dec 16, 2007
  7. smacky

    smacky

    Hey Gang,

    Anybody familiar with Speedtrader? I've used them before years ago and they seemed pretty good.

    I'm going to try the Simulator this week.

    So frustrated with being stabbed in the back by this move to Schwab! I was screwed by Schwab back in late 1999 early 2000 and now I have to deal with these idiots again!

    Unbelievable!! Right when I was really nailin it.........Hard enough to be successful in this biz and then to have this happen!

    I appreciate anyones thoughts!

    Smacky
     
    #347     Dec 16, 2007
  8. AAA
    By law all accounts must be backed by the FDIC. They cover up to $100,000 in cash and all securities. There discount houses do not hold your money. Thats why they use entitys like Penson.

    Its all safe. No need to be so paranoid.
     
    #348     Dec 16, 2007
  9. zdreg

    zdreg

    factually incorrect.
    all accounts are backed by SIPC. they cover up to $500,000 in securities and $100,000 cash.

    in a liquidation all securities are frozen. you cannot close your positions during the liquidation procedure which can take months to complete.
     
    #349     Dec 16, 2007
  10. richk

    richk

    Joybelle,
    it is on you. I just wanted to tell you my 2 cents. I am satisfied with them for long time.
    And do not worry, this is my last post in this thread.
    It looks like you do not want know other possibilities then you discovered already.
    Wish you good selection.
    richard
     
    #350     Dec 16, 2007