Will you stay with Cyber/Schwab if they only offer per trade pricing?

Discussion in 'Retail Brokers' started by Chetnik, Apr 25, 2007.

  1. I traded stocks with CT until last year. My experience was the same. When you wanted to sell, UBSS would hold your order and drop the bid just for a moment, fill you at the low, and the stock would bounce right back. I set the software up to only execute on ECN's.

    So now, they are doing away with the ECN's. It is my opinion, they are doing this so you have to deal with UBSS. They are going to make bags of money.
     
    #191     Oct 27, 2007
  2. akeyla

    akeyla

    Now they have taken manipulation to another level. Whenever you buy or sell through an ECN, UBSS is alerted and makes sure that you sell or cover at a loss through various tactics - some of which I alluded to above.
    I presume since they are only a month or so before integration they've become much more blatant and callous about their cheating.
     
    #192     Oct 27, 2007
  3. buybig

    buybig

    wow, this has got to be one of the most eye opening posts ive seen...

    I currently trade w/ Schwab and though the platform was ok.. starting to realize they want the "whales" w/ the large accounts.

    http://www.schwab.com/public/schwab...es/order_routing_execution/order_routing.html

    ALMOST all orders routed through UBS and expect it to continur for the next 8 years
     
    #193     Oct 27, 2007
  4. Yeah, and it shows what rotten bastards these MM firms are. 99.9% of all orders are non-directed. So, they are going through all this to get rid of the .1% who might have a chance of making some money.

    CT and Schwab don't appear to be as active advertising here any more either. Even this thread doesn't have any of their ads. They don't want our business!

    Bottom line, if you are an active trader, it's time to find a new broker.
     
    #194     Oct 27, 2007
  5. akeyla

    akeyla

    The active advertising has stopped because CT and Schwab have realized that it is an exercise in futility. Most have already deserted ship and scurried for safety seeking shelter amongst more safe havens - comparatively speaking.

    No question about traders finding a new broker because if you don't your account will be zero in a very short time regardless of whether you're day or swing trading. Also realize that most short shares these days are borrowed from Schwab and much less from penson. More incentive to fleece you by forcing you to cover at a loss.
     
    #195     Oct 27, 2007
  6. Dominic

    Dominic

    Well the questions still stands, were have/are current or past active CT customers moving to?
     
    #196     Oct 27, 2007
  7. Has anyone noticed that Schwab/CT is not giving ANY preview of the final version of SS Pro until AFTER you have committed your account to Schwab?

    You need to tell them near the end of November if you don't want your account going to Schwab but they won't let you preview the software until December. I guess were supposed to "just relax" as Schwab's commercials told people to do in the past. Can anyone who trades for a living to support their family make a decision on something sight unseen?


    2 other things to think about.

    (1) If no one else is being allowed into the CT version of SS Pro, how long will Schwab keep that version around? With no new customers entering & typical attrition occurring it makes no sense for them to continue it for any extended period of time. The user base will dissolve away. That seems to make sense to me anyway.

    (2) Where has the Schwab/CT employee named "CT Rep" been? He/she was around here until the questions started coming fast & furious.



    Best of luck with your trading everyone. I wasted a lot of time in this thread. I say "wasted" because nothing has been accomplished in keeping CT around. I'll post again only if something of extreme interest perks my curiosity.

    I'll leave the thread with one quote.

    A quote from CyberTrader CEO Vincent Phillips that he made several years ago.

    ---- CyberTrader supports cross-asset trading and basket trading as well. “They want integration, transparency, and the ability to trade on any venue out there, and our platform is one of the few that offers all that,” Phillips said. He’s optimistic about the business. “As traders become more sophisticated they in turn demand a more sophisticated platform like CyberTrader.” ----

    http://www.windowsfs.com/tabid/54/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/984/Default.aspx

    He's correct. We have become more sophisticated and he's correct we do demand "a more sophisticated platform". I couldn't have said it better myself.

    Good trading all.
     
    #197     Oct 27, 2007
  8. I think some of you are being a bit conspiratorial. The CT platform will be gone. That's a shame but we have to deal with it. CT was never the best platform for scalping. Too expensive. If you don't like USB, you can always use an ECN.

    I think CT Rep will be back when he has solid information. From what I have seen, the new platform will be adequate for day trading, although it is probably more suited for active swing traders. You get the charting and data for free in return for doing a very small number of trades. I don't see a lot of downside to that. You can set up an account with another broker that caters to daytraders and use SSP as your charting app.
     
    #198     Oct 28, 2007
  9. buybig

    buybig

    How would I go about using/setting up an ECN w/ the scwhab software?

    Regarding comment 2.. thats exactlywhat I was thinking about doing. I like the charting

    thx :)
     
    #199     Oct 29, 2007
  10. Dominic

    Dominic

    Can anyone comment if Esignal has similiar charting as CT pro offers?
     
    #200     Oct 29, 2007