Why does TA not work (for you)?

Discussion in 'Technical Analysis' started by Xspurt, Aug 4, 2012.

  1. I can't argue with you. I based that call on info I was getting from a large gold fund-- that was highly accurate previously---- dont ask, but we lost a fortune---obviously, I was following flawed info ....The next year, the fund was up over 100%-- after my clients took a beating.

    Fortunately, I was diversified across 5 non correlated strategies that year. One of which paidi off in a huge way....
     
    #1521     Aug 19, 2012
  2. So you basically admit you were selling the rumor and buying the news. It is axiomatic, but why rely on one tool alone. Very simple TA would have kept you from taking a bath.
     
    #1522     Aug 19, 2012
  3. Surf missed this post...

     
    #1523     Aug 19, 2012
  4. Hindsight IS 20/20
     
    #1524     Aug 19, 2012
  5. #1525     Aug 19, 2012
  6. traderchi128

    traderchi128 Guest

    I think if the person spewing this nonsense had trading credibility, then perhaps it would get better responses. But you don't. Is like a .185 hitter in baseball telling everyone what they should or shouldn't do.
     
    #1526     Aug 19, 2012
  7. Trading is a game of deception, with a sliver of truth here and there. Baron




    Baron
    The Enforcer
    Registered: Apr 1999
    Posts: 2321

    _

    07-04-12 11:18 PM

    Quote from RangeTrader:

    I think it's kind of an honest reflection of trading. Trading is a game of deception, a battle of big ego's, a invisible sliver of truth here and there, and etc...


    One of best assessments of ET I've seen in a long, long time. Very insightful. Someone actually gets it!!
    _ _ Edit/Delete • Quote • Complain
     
    #1527     Aug 19, 2012
  8. Surf played dumb when this was brought up a couple times. Said he didn't remember.

     
    #1528     Aug 19, 2012

  9. What type of response were you expecting?
     
    #1529     Aug 19, 2012
  10. Exactly......

    Surfer can be well described in this paragraph.

    [I have a number of possible explanations for that. Real traders exasperated by pretend traders. Outrage at con artists who hustle the gullible. Posters who pose as gurus but speak in the most turbid turgid manner imaginable. Totally ignorate noobs who seek advice and then argue with you about it. Idiot sponsors who post the same announcement in six different fora. Sock puppets talking to themselves. Trading psychologists who don't trade. Non-native speaker spammers who think they're being subtle. That's just for starters.]

    I feel he is a trading psychologist who does not trade. Especially now that his track record has been put out in the open.

    By the way....
    My nineteen year old son who is in a high level business course (now studying trading) says smurf is an idiot for carrying on about the obvious benefits.
     
    #1530     Aug 19, 2012