Why does TA not work (for you)?

Discussion in 'Technical Analysis' started by Xspurt, Aug 4, 2012.

  1. No, I don't believe in astro trading. You are completely missing the point. But, I don't expect anything else from TA true believers.

    surf
     
    #1361     Aug 16, 2012
  2. First you accuse me of quoting out of context, now you simply assert that the terminology is over everyone's head.

    This from a guy who is constantly asserting that others are using "rhetoric". You sound like a lawyer with a guilty client who can't argue the facts, so he argues the law.

    Might work on TV, but you aren't fooling anyone here.
     
    #1362     Aug 16, 2012
  3. Fah Q

    Fah Q

    but you just said he is the #1 ranked in accuracy for many years. so you are saying he is lucky? what about his track record? you disregard success because it does not align with your beliefs?
     
    #1363     Aug 16, 2012
  4. What else do you think it is -- the Stars control stocks?

    I see I have to really dumb these ideas down here -- but that's ok.

    Just like pointing at supposed succesful TA users message board posters---as evidence of TA working. However, ARCH has one up on you since his results have been documented for years.

    surf:confused:
     
    #1364     Aug 16, 2012
  5. mods it is now time to move this thread to chit chat...pages upon pages of dribble....



    TA doesn't work....

    HELL NO....TA does work


    I say again...TA doesn't work


    Screw you...TA does work
     
    #1365     Aug 16, 2012
  6. Fah Q

    Fah Q


    his results have been documented for years, he is ranked #1 in accuracy and yet you still turn your nose up because it doesnt align with your beliefs.

    i'm not pro or con his type of trading but if he is putting up results and is good, then his method must work.

    it doesnt seem to matter whether someone puts up documented results, even for years, you already have your mind made up about things so what is the point.
     
    #1366     Aug 16, 2012
  7. d08

    d08

    This surf guy is clearly playing with all of us.
    He's not looking for a serious discussion. He has been proven wrong on multiple occasions in this thread, yet when that has happened - he just ignores it and goes back to his initial argument.
    Let him have his fun alone.
     
    #1367     Aug 16, 2012
  8. TheBlackHand

    TheBlackHand Guest

    LOL. It is amusing though.

    I mean, if it did work, why does it take 200+ pages of posts of people trying to convince themselves it does work! Blind leading the blind?
     
    #1368     Aug 16, 2012
  9. Self delusion is a very evident in the market. TA "looks" like it works, so it must work, says the anonymous defender of the faith.

    There are profitable trading methods, TA just isn't one of them.

    There isn't even any evidence of TA working succesfully. just claims upon claims.

    One TA guy even threatened me via PM. Geeeeez!

    surf
     
    #1369     Aug 16, 2012
  10. Fah Q

    Fah Q

    like astro trading right? you believe in that because it's well documented for many years right?

    you brought the subject up and told us all how successful his style has been. so, why do you turn your nose up?
     
    #1370     Aug 16, 2012