I have seen traders crucified and butchered right off ET after posting their trades over time. Not sure why. Possibilities: 1. Not enough details, such as time, entry, exit, stops, etc. 2. Jealousy among readers 3. Too many details 4. Propensity of the poster to argue instead of standing on their results 5. Poster not willing to share their system that got the claimed results 6. Poster not willing to post scans of broker daily summaries 7. Something else that I am missing What say you, ET posters?