What did you think of the stimulus package?

Discussion in 'Economics' started by Ayn Rand, Mar 27, 2020.

  1. disruption insurance.. simple.. just like when people buy insurance against ransomware... a Dental firm was held ransom here in town i'm friends with the IT guy.. They had insurance just for that.. It put them down for a week. Why does it seem so illogical not to rely on the government for EVERYTHING .. your question is posed to me in the light like many other questions. . How could we ever have any roads without goverment.. Roads wouldn't exist, what a miracle goverment is.. omg if we didn't bail out the banks what would happen! maybe people would stop behavinging in ways that put their lives at risk. Instead they incrementlly become suckling dependings on the state and give up liberties for false security... We willl all look back on this with criticisms... now the arguments are phrased like this... who should get more of the money, the workers or the corporations... who do you vote for dem or rep.. ... its binary diaster..
     
    #11     Mar 28, 2020
    SimpleMeLike likes this.
  2. Cuddles

    Cuddles

    & somehow we only hear the other side get blamed for their wishlist

    https://www.politico.com/news/2020/03/26/stimulus-coronavirus-special-deals-151108

    Who got special deals in the stimulus and why they got them

    In the $2 trillion package, senators took care of their home state industries and pet projects.

    In the race to save the economy and pass the largest economic rescue package in American history, Congress still found a way to do some old-fashioned home state favors and reward key special interests.

    Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) managed to successfully push a minimum assistance figure for every state — $1.5 billion — to make sure small states like his weren’t left out in the legislation.

    A provision for the FDA to approve “innovative” sunscreens—which would benefit L’Oreal, which has operations in Kentucky—appeared in the bill, which was steered in the Senate by Majority Leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky. Aides to McConnell said, however, that he did not push for the provision and that it was the result of a bipartisan working group led by other senators working to reform over-the-counter medications.

    The gaming industry wasn’t left out either: Casinos will be able to tap government loans for disaster assistance, a payback after casinos were blocked from receiving tax breaks extended to other businesses after Hurricane Katrina in 2005.

    As the colossal $2 trillion rescue package heads toward President Donald Trump’s desk as soon as this weekend, it’s clear that special interests and members of Congress aren’t letting the pandemic crisis go to waste.

    Here’s a look at a handful of special deals, and how they got into the stimulus:


    Travel agents' relief
    Special deal: The ability to apply for $25 billion in loans and loan guarantees reserved for the airlines.

    How they got it: The airlines used their clout to get tens of billions of dollars in grants and loans included in the bill, but carriers aren’t the only ones who will benefit. The $25 billion allocated in loans and loan guarantees for the airlines will also benefit eligible businesses "approved to perform inspection, repair, replace, or overhaul services, and ticket agents.” The last two words — “ticket agents” — mean that travel agents who book flights will also be able to apply for a piece of the $25 billion.

    Better, faster sunscreen
    Special deal: Tucked in the final bill is language ensuring that the FDA reviews newer and more novel ingredients for over-the-counter sunscreen products in a timely fashion.


    How they got it: The shout-out for sunscreen is part of a long-awaited effort to reform the over-the-counter drug industry, added to the rescue bill amid backing from that industry and various health groups. Besides expanding FDA oversight of over-the-counter products, the provision would streamline the process to change safety labels. Legislation has passed the House and Senate in various forms over the past two years. Last year the Senate easily passed a bill in a 91-2 vote.

    In addition to the over-the-counter reforms, the final relief package makes some updates to the Sunscreen Innovation Act, a 2014 bill co-sponsored by McConnell and signed into law by former President Barack Obama. In a statement at the time, McConnell lamented the slow review of applications for sunscreen ingredients that could potentially be more effective at protecting skin, adding that the bill will benefit Kentucky workers that manufacture “innovative sunscreen ingredients at facilities” in the state.

    Equity for small states
    Special deal: The agreement would provide $150 billion for state and local governments, with no state getting less than $1.5 billion. States are clamoring for help as tax revenue evaporates and unemployment claims climb by the tens of thousands every day.

    How they got it: Leahy, the ranking Democrat on the Senate Appropriations Committee, represents Vermont. He told reporters on Thursday that he pushed for language to ensure that small states don’t lose out on emergency funds.

    Job security for military brass

    Special deal: The rescue package permits Trump to extend the terms of up to seven senior military leaders: the Air Force chief of staff; the chief of space operations; the chief of the National Guard Bureau; the directors of the Army and Air National Guard; and the chief of the Army and Navy Reserves. Many of those top officers' terms are set to expire later this year. The provision would permit Trump to keep these current leaders in the job until successors are confirmed.

    How they got it: The provision was included in an initial Senate Republican version of the stimulus and has the backing of the Senate Armed Services Committee. The aim is to give Trump options to fill top leadership posts amid the coronavirus crisis. “At this unprecedented time, the committee and the administration wanted to ensure we have every possible option available to keep critical military positions filled,” Marta Hernandez, a committee spokesperson, said.


    A win for the credit reporting industry
    Special deal: Consumers wouldn't get a negative credit report if they have an agreement with a lender to delay payments or make partial payments. That was a way to stave off a total ban on negative credit reports during the crisis. The credit reporting industry contended a total ban would have been highly damaging to its products.

    How they got it: Democrats like Sens. Sherrod Brown of Ohio and Brian Schatz of Hawaii unsuccessfully pushed for the ban, in addition to access to free credit reports and scores. It’s not the first win for credit reporting companies. During Congress' last major revamp of financial regulations in 2018, the industry overcame backlash from the massive Equifax data breach when it won language providing a shield from consumer lawsuits related to a free credit monitoring requirement in the bill.


    Student loan tax boon

    Special deal: The final package creates a new tax benefit for student loan borrowers whose employers help them pay off their debt. Under the bill, a company could pay up to $5,250 of an employee’s student loan payments each year on a tax-free basis.

    How they got it: The provision stems from a bipartisan proposal circulating on Capitol Hill for the last few years, most recently pushed by Sens. John Thune (R-S.D.) and Mark Warner (D-Va.), large employers and college groups. Reps. Rodney Davis (R-Ill.) and Scott Peters (D-Calif.) have also introduced a companion bill in the House. Some critics, however, have said it will provide new tax benefits to financially secure, well-off borrowers who don’t need the help.

    Casinos roll the dice and win
    Special deal: Casinos pushed for provisions to make sure they wouldn’t be blocked from federal aid. They're allowed to apply for portions of the $350 billion in Small Business Administration loans if they’re a small business and need less than $10 million. Larger casinos can apply for $454 billion in loans backed by Treasury.

    How they got it: Casinos were afraid of being excluded. The industry sought to make sure the bill didn’t include any provisions that would block MGM Resorts International, Wynn Resorts, Las Vegas Sands or its other members from getting the same help as other industries.


    Free video visitation in prison

    Special deal: The legislation will mean free video conference and phone calls for inmates during the pandemic, if Attorney General Bill Barr agrees.

    How they got it: As the pandemic spread throughout the U.S., prisons canceled normal visiting hours and closed facilities to outside visitors. And inmates typically face higher-than-usual charges for calling those outside the prison grounds, an issue that the Federal Communications Commission and some lawmakers have tried to address in the past. Last week, Sen. Cory Booker (D-N.J.) pressed the Bureau of Prisons to allow inmate phone calls and videoconferencing for free during the pandemic and touted a victory following the Senate’s passage of the relief measure.

    Harbor dredging help
    Special deal: The deal includes language making it easier for Congress to dole out money for harbor dredging by exempting from discretionary spending caps the Army Corps of Engineers funding provided through the Harbor Maintenance Trust Fund. The provision is a boon for ports that need dredging work, like the one in Mobile, Ala., in Senate Appropriations Chairman Richard Shelby's (R-Ala.) home state.

    How they got it: Prominent backers of the push include Shelby and House Transportation and Infrastructure Chairman Peter DeFazio (D-Ore.). Shelby has fought repeatedly with his own party over the issue. One Republican aide called the decision “an easy give to Shelby, since he’s been wanting it for years and now why not give it to him?”

    Relief for farmers
    Special deal: The stimulus provides $9.5 billion in emergency aid for the agriculture industry and replenishes $14 billion in spending authority to the Agriculture Department’s Commodity Credit Corp., a Depression-era financial institution set up to stabilize the farm economy — the same USDA agency sending trade bailout payments to farmers. Producers ranging from dairy farmers and cattle ranchers to fresh fruit and vegetable growers are eligible.

    How they got it: Livestock groups have been leaning on lawmakers for weeks to pony up funds for producers who have seen commodity prices plummet since January. Western senators including John Hoeven (R-N.D.), who chairs the Appropriations panel that oversees agricultural spending, made sure those provisions were part of the stimulus plan from the get-go. Then, top Democrats like Michigan Sen. Debbie Stabenow, ranking member on the Agriculture Committee, pushed to include language making specialty crop farmers — like Michigan’s tart cherry growers — eligible for the emergency aid.
     
    #12     Mar 28, 2020
  3. LS1Z28

    LS1Z28

    I have very mixed feelings about the stimulus bill. Part of a fair market society is allowing businesses to fail. But at the same time, the government has forced businesses to shut down throughout much of the country. So to some extent, the government is responsible for the economic downturn. They probably have a responsibility to keep businesses from failing.

    Everyone will talk about the corporate bailouts, but the corporations are receiving loans that have to be paid back with interest. Plus they'll have restrictions on things like stock buybacks & executive pay until the loans are paid back. The real bailouts are going towards individuals & small businesses. Individuals are getting cash payments with no strings attached, and small businesses are getting loan forgiveness if they maintain their staffs for 2 months.

    I'll be surprised if we don't see another round of stimulus, because the money provided to state & local governments won't come close to making up for the revenue they've lost. Most states will face significant budget deficits soon. When all of the dust settle, we will have added a significant amount of money to our deficit.
     
    #13     Mar 28, 2020
    Ayn Rand likes this.
  4. Cuddles

    Cuddles

    https://www.politico.com/news/2020/03/27/congress-coronavirus-bank-rescue-152501

    Washington quietly prepares a bank rescue — just in case

    Washington's move to stand behind the banking industry underscores the aggressive efforts to prepare for the worst.
     
    #14     Mar 28, 2020
  5. I agree with you cdcaveman.

    Depending on the goverment is like depending on a dog to not like candy off the ground.

    I think business owners learned a valuable lesson in what type of insurance to get. It is best to get ALLL the insurances you think that could prevent your business from making money if customers do not show up due to act of nature or virus event.

    As far as people goes:: Save 12 months of living expense before doing anything else.
     
    #15     Mar 28, 2020
    cdcaveman likes this.
  6. I know a small City in which I live that has been prudent in keep taxes low and spending wisely....one thing they did was bought more water rights then they needed..... Then sold those rights to city's adjacent to us later on and stocked reserves.. so now our city for this and many other prudent financial decisions doesn't need money... Many city's that made poor decisions will need money... Plenty of cities out there rife with pension debt and poorly managed coffers will get rewarded for their bad behavior by this stimulus.... Yet the majority American public is behind broad stimulus....penalizing prudence agents for good financial making and rewarding bad decisions and behavior is in no way a good way to recovery...anyone got a valid argument against this I'm open ears
     
    #16     Mar 28, 2020
    LS1Z28 likes this.