What are the safest futures brokers? MF Global and PFGBest have me worried!

Discussion in 'Retail Brokers' started by travelingtrader, Jul 10, 2012.

  1. jonlgan

    jonlgan

    I had used PFGBest's demo account and liked some of their educational options but never opened account. I use Interactive Brokers for my futures trading and have always found them to be the best.
     
    #41     Jul 11, 2012
  2. irniger

    irniger

  3. So should all American futures traders open accounts with brokers in Canada or Europe?
     
    #43     Jul 11, 2012
  4. luisHK

    luisHK

    Any good one you could recommend there ? I've started checking Canada but found mostly equities broker, and no one in Europe with competitive rates.
     
    #44     Jul 11, 2012
  5. #45     Jul 11, 2012
  6. carpani

    carpani

    The atlas ratings appear pretty accurate and I recently closed an account at MB trading due to their buggy systems, lack of customer service, control issues. Looking at Atlas ratings they're in the bottom of the list since they use Penson Financial Services as agent so beware. I would think people would look at these ratings and seriously consider moving to brokers up the rating list. Surprisingly alot of folks are on there towards the bottom that folks brag about (OEC, Velocity, FCM, RCG, etc). Seems like its not worth taking the risk even if you get some money back after 1 year of hassles and distractions caused by the next one to go under. Opportunity cost in a situation like that would be huge.
     
    #46     Jul 15, 2012
  7. PFG are/were in Canada but not a discount broker, a 'deal' was done with the individual
    account rep based on account min and trades volume

    http://www.globalsec.com/ originally was futures only, re-"founded in 1987 as a full-
    service brokerage firm"; rt comm is $80 , also offer additional insurance up to $10M

    there are other futures brokers or via banks but don't believe there's any discounters

    Europe including the UK provides around €40/$50K insurance - as a last resort after
    all other means of collecting client funds have been exhausted
     
    #47     Jul 15, 2012
  8. Maybe we should invest into IBKR since it seems a lot of traders are moving into it based on new panics.
     
    #48     Jul 15, 2012
  9. If you do a quick search, www.atlasratings.com is registered to mkcglobal.com and Andrew McCormick -

    http://www.networksolutions.com/whois-search/atlasratings.com

    If you follow this you find - http://www.mkcglobal.com/contactus.html - the same guy.

    Looks like a very small one man shop. Maybe that is why he does not realize that his list makes no sense. For example, OEC is owned by Schwab. At the close of business Friday, SCHW had a market cap of over $16B (yes with a B). It is comical this one man band can't even figure that out.
     
    #49     Jul 15, 2012
  10. no, but I bet Lloyds could figure it out. When they get Flo to start advertising portfolio insurance on CNBC I may give them a call. I'd rather deal with the insurance company than the SIPC. The difference is, Flo doesn't really care what car you drive. Lloyds would keep a close eye on the broker.
     
    #50     Jul 15, 2012