It is clear as a sharp whistle. I am sure she “hears”. BTW is it cold in Canada right now? I have a good friend who lives in Alberta near Edmonton. All trading education is generally rehashed and relabeled stuff even the so called new fangled “indicators”. Nothing is really “new”. All things in the markets chug along as they have for the last 100 years. You got winners and you got losers. And you got some that apparently can’t do either. Guess which category Dozzy is in.
Others and now I are posting questions about the terminology (not the charts)...questions not answer. Nothing to do with any agreements about the charts. Once again, they are pretty charts...its the terminology / phrases although someone (not me) pointed to an issue with words (then/than) but I still understood and make the same mistake sometimes. Regardless, my agenda is to get the questions answer. I'm not here to attack nor praise the charts especially when I've seen it before here at Elitetrader.com (not sure about Tradingview) By the way, never been to Alberta but I've heard there's a few places there for good Pheasant Hunting. Strongly agree...thank you. That's my other agenda because that point had seemed prior to fall upon deaf ears. As I recently stated... Its a new coat of paint on the same wall. Maybe we can now get some questions answered by Erin and move on. Do you think that will happen ? (sarcasm to lighten things up) wrbtrader
Let me address this - first... 'Tradingview.com which is where Erin hangs out'... actually I do not hang out anywhere, I have trading friends on several sites. I have one friend here on ET who has been affected by covid and I am patiently waiting to see how he is fairing. Secondly... 'Its a nice website full of technical traders using indicators, oscillators and price action traders. Most have their own unique understanding of price action. Thus, if you have something to say, its very difficult to get views on what you have to say and/or to feel like you're being heard.' ...There are actually very few price action traders as most fail to understand the concepts therefore cannot execute the trade properly. I am well known for my price action theory and I am not worried about being heard. You never have to worry about being heard if you understand what you are talking about. Thirdly... 'Yet, it would be problematic if they arrive here and think their view is the only right view when they think they don't see a lot of current discussions about price action trading while they don't realize its all been discussed before...that's when problems happen.'...I believe every topic has been overkilled here, but it appears because price action has been discussed in the past it should be removed from all threads now - is that what I am hearing and no I have never said my views are ...the only right view... Fourthly... 'By the way, the gender thing doesn't phase me and we all know what happen the last time when a gender thing became an issue after so many members ignored the tell tale signs'...gender has nothing to do with trading. Next... 'Personally, Elitetrader.com is the last social media place I would post any education info about price action trading. Many years ago it was suitable for such like the early 2000's but things changed around the 2008 - 2010 global financial crisis and the rise of Twitter, Stocktwits and TradingView.'...what you do or don't do is your own personal business. Next... 'Elitetrader.com is now to me just as a place to hang out and drink some beers...that's a good thing too. Less crowded about trading issues...reason why I get my fill of technical trading from elsewhere although this place may be more attractive to newbies looking for a place to be heard and even get answers about topics not even related to trading if that's what they really needed.'...I never swill beer and make outrageous passive aggressive attacks against another trader, it is not my style nor who I am. I have a little more pride than that and a little more respect for other traders.
Mickey If you were here I would serve you a fresh cup of 8’oclock coffee. As my uncle once said to my Dad upon being asked how he liked that 8’oclock coffee. He responded: “it is A REAL EYE OPENER!”
@WRB ...you didn’t answer my Dozzy question. What category do you think he is in? I gotta run. Momma is in the garden and wanting help. Am I hen pecked or what?
I see you're a little not use to quoting others but I am able to select your words (replies) merged in there among my prior statement. It's easy...just click the quote...you don't need to post your reply inside the quote. My point, your charts come from TradingView and TradingView is much better for technical analysis discussions. We here at ET all know that and its just the way the forum here is designed. Simply, not something to disagree about nor worth talking about. Thus, not a personal issue its just the way the forum is today...different from the way it use to be in the early 2000's prior the addition of chit chat, politics, spiritual and other non trading topics. Never accused you of drinking beer here nor via any indirect statements. Instead, I made a joke about myself involving my use of the forum. I'm still waiting for the terminology explanations that others have asked...I have the same curiosity. wrbtrader
I'm still trying to figure that out...what does that mean (Dozzy) ? You talking about another member name dozu888...the guy with the "Trading is Easy" thread ??? https://www.elitetrader.com/et/threads/trading-is-easy.321831/ wrbtrader
Im not interested in providing any more on this discussion. You have won. I will leave. I think this thread will be fair warning to any new ET member who wishes to discuss a topic that it is not welcome here, nor are their comments. You and Micky would not even let me off first base to discuss this topic or delve any further then the scratch I made on the surface. On to your next victim - well played.
I'm not sure why you're having difficulties or reluctance in answering questions by others but it was something I initially notice was very odd. I then brushed it off that you're new to this forum and maybe was too shy to respond. Yet, then I notice how Mickey was posting his question...he didn't quote you and he didn't use your user name. Instead, he called you OP (it means the person that started the thread as in you but I wasn't sure you knew that considering you didn't respond to his question). I responded to him (not to you) that he needs to quote you and that would in turn alert (after you log in...you'll see your alerts in the upper right corner) you to questions being ask. I even told him that his use of the name OP is something you may not be use to seeing. Thus, you're not going to view the question as one for you. Also, I'm not sure why it bothers you that I pointed out the fact that you do not or maybe do not want to answer those questions by others. Yet, I am very curious about the terminology usage too. Without that info, as others suggested...its difficult to understand what you're saying on the charts regardless how nice the charts look but nothing new except for the terminology. Seriously, if you want a constructive discussion about your opinions about price action...one of the most important things you got to do is answer basic questions and not be offended when someone like me "keeps hammering" the same question. Your reaction is as if the questions is like a gun to your head or someone is making you walk the plank. Take a look at the other TA discussion threads @ https://www.elitetrader.com/et/forums/technical-analysis.33/ Questions in those threads are more in-depth than here in your thread in which people are only asking you to define a term you're using. In fact, in those other TA threads...members debate, attack the merits of TA...none of that is occurring here in your thread. In those other TA threads, members ask for verification, statistical analysis, simulation trading results...none of that is occurring here in your thread. The only threatening thing I see in this thread was someone correcting you about your English involving the use of then / than...it was very confusing to him but OK with me. My beef or agenda is that I notice something very odd... Your inability to answer simple questions because they're attacking you...really ??? I won't bother to repost the other simple questions...they may be too threatening although I'm just as curious too about your definitions of your terminology. Your reaction now has me curious about your psychology or agenda when such curiosity didn't exist for me until you reacted this way. wrbtrader
You really need to use the ignore/block function. It reduces a substantial amount of noise. I'm always interested in seeing other views of the market, please continue.