May I offer a suggestion? In MT4 or 5 you can make the trades that you made visible. Switch to a 1H. See if those trades would have made sense on a 1H; Brooks style... Everyone I know who's profitable in this game, uses multiple TF's.
it is important first to decide is it a range or a trend.......if range fade big bars /moves.....if trend enter in the same direction as the big bars