JJ I didn't want to get into a beef with you on this, but it looks like Spydertrader's comment about the ES dropping 10 points seconds after T28 posted is total BS. Which means that Spydertrader's the one who's busted. Are you claiming the ES did drop like that? The fact that I don't trade futures only means I don't have the data to look at 1 min ES bars. And even if it did happen, SO WHAT. Everyone's acting like nobody who "really trades" is ever on the wrong side of the market which is ridiculous. Look at Warren Buffett's drawdown. Oh yeah, I forgot that Jack can outperform him. Bad example, sorry. I never tested PVT in its entirety and never claimed to. And I doubt you did either because based on what Jack described you would have needed the ability to screen stocks for whether or not they met fundamental criteria in the PAST, you would have needed years of intraday data on those stocks, etc. And even if that tiny piece you tested was approximately correct, I wouldn't exactly give PVT's performance of roughly half of buy and hold rave reviews without seeing other stats, like % time in the market, drawdown, etc.
It took minutes, when it started, it was unremitting ... obviously, Trader28 was wrong. Yeah, I agree with you about the "so what" thing, it's just another trade ... but the fact that Trader28 deleted his posts, said he was looking for support to hold and then turn around (ranting and raving) and pretended that he was short from the apex of the move, should tell you something, and if it doesn't, we really don't have anything else to say to each other, now do we? Speaking of PVT, I used an approved list of stocks (approve by Jack Hershey) and applied them to the automated trading code that spydertrader was kind of enough to freely provide the board. Now if that isn't good enough for you, and you want to continue arguing over the interent and belaboring the point, I like Vikana, will just turn a blind to you and your insistence on being obstinate. Trader28 is his on little troll, who no one (especially Baron) even wants on the site. If you want to continue using the type of "idiot-logic" that he expouses, you can be put in that category as well. Yep, a pity you'll never do the work required to produce these stats and will always question the results of anyone else who does. :eek:
Where's support? ... LOL If you don't know where that is, it's highly doubtful that you know what you're looking at on the chart that I was kind enough to supply the board (for which I am eternally grateful, LOL).
Good luck JJ... you'll need it. P.S. I guess the lying and stupidity is infectious? Maybe there's a lying and stupidity virus in the koolaid? Because vikana thanked me in the final post of the thread. I guess if you want to call that turning a blind eye, you'll fit in well in candyland. http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&postid=1980002#post1980002
Is being obstinate, trollish and stupid contagious? Because it seems that you've been hanging out with your buddy Trader28 for a little too long there. Good luck with your "stock trading analysis", LOL, I hope it proves what you want it too.
I'm really glad that support held for you when you called it ... oops, it didn't! :eek: Trader28 can't tell up from down
Bwahahaha you have over 20 aliases in under 6 months You and your friend Trader666 are the local village idiots. Trader666 and Trader28, Brothers (the thumbs up was to GO LONG on Wednesday :eek: ).
JJ, if you had ANY integrity at all, you wouldn't link to that post once you were shown that what Spydertrader said the ES did was bullshit.
Trader666, if you had ANY integrity at all, you wouldn't support Trader28 in his rants, after it was shown that what he said was complete and total bullshit (and he posted porn, which he probably looks at all day while blathering on ET and pretending to trade). Since you weren't watching the markets (you don't trade futures) or his call (you weren't on the thread), you didn't see what happened ... that bad boy dropped, and Trader28 went scrambling for cover. It was pretty bad, hell I wanted to defend him, but I couldn't, it was just too obvious that he didn't know what the hell he was talking about. Maybe he should invest in one of the publicly sold canned systems, his SPM isn't doing him much good, these days. :eek: P.S. I hear Steve46 is teaching remedial lessons in trading using volume bars and moving averages ... maybe that can help him.