trading platform comparsion for scalping

Discussion in 'Index Futures' started by milstar, Jul 20, 2005.

  1. milstar

    milstar

    Gentlemen

    Author interessed for information about trading platform
    for e-mini . Most important Depth of the market and possibility
    of speedy /0.1 sec/ entry/order kill for tactic win spread
    /buy on bid ,sell on ask /. No graphics &

    Exist this kind platform wihtout downloading with java push ?
    Some of platform's was tested from author

    Ninja - need additional downloading of 25 mb .net ,which
    is source of instability and viruses. tested
    Onyx - need .net not tested

    J-trader -need additional downlading of SUN platform ,
    tested not stable ,infected with viruse's
    PFGBest - some 10 MB ,system crashed by trading contest

    REFCCO/LIND -Xpress 5.7 MB ,have lite version ,stability is good ,but worst for speedy entry . By lite version different
    pop-windows are source of delay in 10-15 seconds .

    SR -12.4 MB .Who tested ?

    Infinity pro - need .net .Who tested ?

    Openecry -need only 1.5 mb downloading .Some speedy
    entry possible with DOME ,no lite version ,which
    work without downloading .

    Author would very pleased for additional information .
     
  2. Truff

    Truff

    Look at Trademaven or CQG
     
  3. JayS

    JayS

    X_Trader or CQG Trader.
     
  4. FredBloggs

    FredBloggs Guest

    get a copy of a good anti virus solution - norton or something - seems to be most of your problems.

    also, try refco pro.

    xpress isnt so bad.

    lags may occur due to internet connectivity
     
  5. milstar

    milstar

    get a copy of a good anti virus solution - norton or something - seems to be most of your problems.
    also, try refco pro.
    xpress isnt so bad.
    lags may occur due to internet connectivity


    1. Some of complex platform work with java push without
    downloading ,as example ameritrade streamer .
    It work not in each situation ,but exist lite version http .

    Optionsxpress streamer ,or archipelago book work in each access ,which author tested in Hamburg

    2. Where is platform with equal stability for future trading ?
     
  6. milstar

    milstar

    Tested this time Infinity pro with .net


    From first attempt to login - login is false
    folloving -some another person used this version
    user account dissabled &

    From first day of testing from start !
     
  7. I think your computer has problems.

    I have not tried some of the platforms you've mentioned, but I have tried a few of em. I've NEVER had a virus from a trading platform. I have NEVER had any major problems with the more popular ones you've mentioned as far as bugs/login issues/crashing. You need to do a virus/spyware scrub.

    Also, if you're looking for ultimate speed, your problem with some of them is likely due to .net/java. You're going to want compiled code, not interpreted. Open E Cry, X_Trader, and CQG Trader are all written in C++. These should be the fastest of the bunch.

    On the other hand, the speed of the software is likely moot in 99% of cases, as the real speed culprit (as mentioned perviously, by FuturesTrader71, I believe) is your internet/data connection. If you're running standard cable or DSL internet and trying to scalp from home, you'll be at a speed disadvantage to those like Futurestrader71, who have dedicated direct lines to their data.

    I'm not saying you can't scalp from home, but I am saying you're at a disavantage and it is not because of your software.

    Disclaimer: I am not a scalper. I never have been. But I also know I cannot be one because of my current setup, which uses Tradestation and standard DSL.
     
  8. milstar

    milstar

    Try to test this time

    Work from start .First impression ,overloaded with information,which auhtor need not .Lite /http/version
    as by REFCO/Lind-Waldock not exist

    Exist customization ,will try ...

    Which of operator can compare SR/12 MB/ with Xpress ?
    both platform advantage's and dissadvantage's from
    experience.Most important speed and stabiltiy
     
  9. milstar

    milstar

    If Trademaven = Tradebolt ,this have not DOME
    X-trader need downloading .how many MB ?
    based sun or .net ?

    Some information from experienced user of X-trader
    CQG welcome
     
  10. milstar

    milstar

    you'll be at a speed disadvantage to those like Futurestrader71, who have dedicated direct lines to their data.


    As author is Germany based ,he's speed dissadvantaged,but
    some 5 business day result of the author by USA based real quote/paper money futures contest as 2600% /"by multiple author discrimination from organisator " - from complaint to CFTC/
    stated ,that possible exist chanse for small operator .
    Important question ,that by paper game not clear how
    used CME rule first in-first out .
    In realy money trading MM can block this kind of operator acitivities
     
    #10     Jul 20, 2005