Trading is Gambling. You know it! Be honest

Discussion in 'Psychology' started by ElectricSavant, Nov 19, 2006.

Gambling?

  1. Yes

    19 vote(s)
    45.2%
  2. no, I am lieng to myself

    23 vote(s)
    54.8%
  1. Are you a TraderClone? or are you being honest?

    When you pull the trigger do you believe you are "Gambling"? or do you "feel" it.

    is gambling a "feeling" or a "Belief"?

    when you manage risk are you managing "Gambling"..what do you believe?

    Folks the votes are coming in...here is your chance to "not vote"...
     
    #31     Nov 19, 2006
  2. When your trading, does the use of stops manage your gambling?
     
    #32     Nov 19, 2006
  3. When your gambling do you sing? Do you have off days?

    Can Trading be an addiction?
     
    #33     Nov 19, 2006
  4. GAMBLE----1: to play a game for money, 2: or to bet on an uncertain outcome, 3: or an act having an element of risk, 4: the playing of a game of chance for stakes.

    Is trading a game for money? Kind of a serious game.

    There is an uncertain outcome for each trade, although there is the % probability that the trade will be profitable and yield a probable $ amount.

    There is an element of managed risk for each trade.

    Is trading a game of chance? There is skill involved. It's not a role of the dice if you have a profitable method.
     
    #34     Nov 19, 2006
  5. are the stakes better defined within trading or Gambling? do you have any control in either?
     
    #35     Nov 19, 2006
  6. Trading isn't gambling till execution? Are intraday traders in need of therapy, they gamble more than swingers?
     
    #36     Nov 19, 2006
  7. Blackjack... playing the odds, probability... just as much skill in some forms of betting, professionals pick horse flesh the way a pro picks stocks

    and some traders on the other hand pick a direction on a whim, just like the toss of a coin or the throw of a dice

    We call pro's traders and losers gamblers... it's all semantics

    Professional gamblers would slaughter 95% of so called traders if this was their game
     
    #37     Nov 19, 2006
  8. ummm...we have already agreed playing proper blackjack while keeping accurate track of a plus and minus count in time will be 'not gambling' haven't we? or does the dictionary definition of the sky is falling apply there too?

    trading is Gambling...because the risk is unknown and the outcome is yet to be seen...

    we persuade ourselves that it is a safe bet through our timeless analysis in Trading.

    nobody really knows that they will bank $'s...no matter how safe they believe it is ...

    Michael B.

    do the Casinos gamble....? If not...Can traders "not Gamble" ?

    hmmm...sounds like a "no vote" to me :)



     
    #38     Nov 19, 2006

  9. Finally an example of not gambling... the roulette wheel... the casino cannot lose, but really that one green zero is more like a brokerage fee for letting losers place a 50/50 bet that only pays out 48.648%

    Trading is more akin to blackjack in that you can use an edge to put probability on your side, but even then if you have the same hand as the house then the house wins and that constitutes a brokerage fee... but at least unlike roulette you have a slim chance of developing a system that can overcome the fee... roulette the odds are set in stone and an edge cannot be devised
     
    #39     Nov 19, 2006
  10. Ok show your colors...is it red or black...

    All you winning Gamblers and Consistently Lucky traders are invited to 'not Vote"...:)
     
    #40     Nov 19, 2006