Not entirely correct.... It seems there were varied reactions... from poppycock to unsubstantiated to... "My reading of the article you sent is Bridle is over-interpreting our results," David Walt, a professor at Harvard Medical School and the study's co-author, said in an email to USA TODAY.
You can go contact the professors at Duke and Havad who wrote the study. They will be happy to outline where Biddle is wrong point-by-point about the study they authored. They will also be happy to explain to you why Biddle is a complete clown show.
Look asshole... I am not arguing this guy is correct. Just as he may be overstating to one side... it appears you are also overstating some things... (but at the moment you do seem to closer to correct side)...
Since you agree the guy is not correct then his perspectives are meaningless..... and you have nothing to argue about. So hush up.
I think he does a bit or quite a bit of speculation If after reading enough of the science I have a feel... then I will evaluate... for now I think it makes more sense go with the author's of the studies views. I can not really say who is correct... I don't the knowledge base.