The Trouble With Scribbles

Discussion in 'Technical Analysis' started by Buy1Sell2, Mar 30, 2015.

  1. fortydraws

    fortydraws

    For example, long 4400.50 with a 5 point hard stop, but based on current PA if price moves below 4400.25 and doesn't pop back up immediately, I'd cut the loss and re-evaluate. 5 point hard stop is for "worst case." but monitor PA to tell you if the market is looking more likely to move opposite of your positions. I use the flow of price and where it has to go to find bids. If this gets to +5 I will be at breakeven +2 ticks.

    EDIT: +5 points (if I see 4405.5 offered, I will move my hard stop).
     
    #421     Apr 14, 2015
    timokrates and dbphoenix like this.
  2. fortydraws

    fortydraws

    Was filled on planned partial exit 5.50 offer. 4401 hard stop, but looking at possible DT fail. I really don't like doing this, so I'm going to sign off.

    EDIT: with retail sales coming out in about 5 or six minutes, 4401 looks like a good place for me to be out. I have limit offers at 4408 & 4410 to take a few more, and I'll see what happens after that, if NQ trades to those levels or higher. Right now price pulled back to 4401.75, with a potential lower high at 4405.25, so scribblers know what we are looking for ...
     
    Last edited: Apr 14, 2015
    #422     Apr 14, 2015
    dbphoenix likes this.
  3. dbphoenix

    dbphoenix

    I should point out that though there are only three strategies -- reversals, breakouts, and retracements -- the variety of tactics to implement these strategies are near limitless. Thus no two Scribblers will enter in exactly the same place with exactly the same "stop", nor will they have exactly the same price objectives as they do not trade exactly the same number of contracts nor scale out in exactly the same way. Nor do they all trade exactly the same bar interval nor exactly the same timeframe.
     
    #423     Apr 14, 2015
  4. fortydraws

    fortydraws

    Some scribblers trade all hours of the day. For myself, I do not trade premkt very often, but when I see what looks like a probable 5 point trade, I will take it. I also manage my trades differently premkt vs AM session vs afternoon session and I tend not to be too quick to take a new position during the mid-day doldrums. I am also more happy to be flat or with a better than breakeven stop as news comes out.
     
    #424     Apr 14, 2015
  5. dbphoenix

    dbphoenix

    And now a range from 98 to 05 is shaping up. That the median of this range is 1.5pts above equilibrium is not necessarily important.
     
    #425     Apr 14, 2015
  6. fortydraws

    fortydraws

    Another reason to keep in mind that distinguishing between ranges and trending moves and identifying the limits of current and recent ranges is to frame market context, not give one "The Trade." Context tells you where to look for potential trades. It is up to the trader to select the appropriate strategy and tactics. Again, this is not a "system." If what one wants is to find a system that removes all responsibility and decision making from the trader - a system that tells one when to enter, and in which direction, and at what exact price, and when to exit, and what exact price, then scribbles is not for that individual. That doesn't make that trader "wrong," but neither does it make the scribblers "wrong". There truly are many ways to skin this cat.
     
    #426     Apr 14, 2015
  7. dbphoenix

    dbphoenix

    Those who understand what equilibrium is will also understand that trading in it or around it leads to a lot of whipsawing. Setting a wide stop and hoping for the best is not prudent.
     
    #427     Apr 14, 2015
  8. Im not talking about the past. Why not post video of trades here and now? Don't try to deflect back to the questioner or point toward the past as an answer. Just admit you can't do it.

    surf
     
    #428     Apr 14, 2015
  9. Is this even remotely correct, or not?
     
    • ed.jpg
      ed.jpg
      File size:
      78.3 KB
      Views:
      82
    #429     Apr 14, 2015
    lajax and toucan like this.
  10. dbphoenix

    dbphoenix

    I can do it. I just don't see the point.

    And trying to deflect your own lack of transparency onto others is pretty transparent itself.
     
    #430     Apr 14, 2015
    fortydraws likes this.