The Price Action Journal

Discussion in 'Journals' started by SusanaDT, Jul 19, 2008.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. amitman

    amitman

    My contribution for this great thread.
    Had to leave early today so I've missed some nice moves (and at least one 10 points trade) but I can't complain, very happy with my trading today.

    BTW, for those who asked me is several places. I DO NOT use this 10,000 Vol chart as my main chart. I just use it as one more chart (along with 4 range bars and 1 minute charts) and sometimes for my entries and exits too. I do use some indicators (only 2 HMA's for visual aid) but for the sake of this thread I post my charts like Susana's charts.

    Edit:
    The first comment on the chart should be R into S and not vice versa, my apologies.
     
    #251     Jul 30, 2008
  2. Thank you moderators for cleaning the trash off this journal.

    Had an amazing trading day, ES has been a flower lately.

    Would like to see experienced traders contributing to the journal please, I'm also a student here, otherwise will just grow tired.

    Thank you.

    Susana
     
    #252     Jul 31, 2008
  3. Hi Susana,

    I posted a message a few pages back, not sure if you saw it so I will post it again.

    I might have missed something while looking at your charts. How do you know with a high degree of certainty that the trend has changed? What do you look for to determine a change of trend?

    Thank you,

    Floyd

     
    #253     Jul 31, 2008
  4. Floyd,

    It's very simple and don't let anyone tell you differently.

    Support is always support until it becomes resistance.

    Resistance is always resitance until it becomes support.

    The rest is highs and lows.

    Susana
     
    #254     Jul 31, 2008

  5. When you look at a 1 min or 3 min chart you will see in hindsight that a change in trend is often reflected in the price action even at the start of the move. As Saliva said PMT.
    Look at the WRB wide range bars at the start of the move, there relation in size to the previous bars in the opposite direction etc

    So once Support resistance and price action indicate a change in trend or a start of a move I look to buy/sell pullbacks...simple :D
     
    #255     Jul 31, 2008
  6. amitman

    amitman

    Dear Susana,
    agian, not that I'm a better trader but just notice that your only losing trade yesterday was a counter trend trade.
    There was a obvious double top followed by a LL and a LH and if I remeber right according to AHG this is at least a sign of cosolidation, no to mention a trend change. But still, although you've noticed all these things you still entered long, and lost.
    just my 2 cents...
     
    #256     Jul 31, 2008
  7. Not taking support into consideration, AHG calls for a downtrend when a DT, LL and LH form. Typically very high R:R plays at that, especially if the DT is at R!
     
    #257     Jul 31, 2008
  8. Anybody pulling out the performance that you are pulling in points per contract in real life, is in the top 0.25% of traders in the world skillwise.

    At some point you will have to face the size demon, which is the last demon guarding the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. It is an ugly bastard.

    Additional improvement in your demonstrated PA skills will bring only marginal bottom line results. Only size increase will impact in a big way your performance from this point on. You have probably heard that before too.

    The odds say that you are unlikely to see many of the 0.25% traders in your league with better points per contract results. But I never believed much in odds.

    The above is my opinion only of course.

    Thanks for starting the thread. I have learned from it.

    Good luck and continued volatility in your journey.
     
    #258     Jul 31, 2008
  9. Here's an idea, one which I'm sure you've had before.

    Only take the trades in the direction of the dominant trend.

    Using yesterday's trades as an example, using the daily OHLC to determine the trend and investor sentiment for the day you would only have taken LONGS.

    Looking at today's chart, you would only look for SHORTS.

    Just a thought.

    Good trading.
     
    #259     Jul 31, 2008
  10. alea jacta est,

    don't cross the rubicon. (that's supposed to be a joke)

    serious question:

    on your chart, are your price bars constant volume bars? If so, what volume, 10,000?
     
    #260     Jul 31, 2008
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.