The myth of volume as a leading indicator of price direction...

Discussion in 'Technical Analysis' started by HolyGrailSeeker, Aug 8, 2021.

  1. userque

    userque

    Ok, well that changes the math problem a bit.

    Your original statement was general, but I now assume you are only referring to intraday. You seem to be saying that morning volume is correlated to the range in the future (afternoon, etc.).

    For someone to test/verify this, they would have to know the time frame in which to measure the morning volume; and the subsequent time frame in which to measure the range.

    It seems you would be in the best position to confirm your observation, no? As you know exactly the criteria.
     
    #31     Aug 14, 2021
  2. userque

    userque

    #32     Aug 14, 2021
  3. Overnight

    Overnight

    *spits beverage at screen.* That's 2001! TWENTY YEARS ago! Dude, run it again for the last couple of years?
     
    #33     Aug 14, 2021
    SunTrader likes this.
  4. NazSherpa

    NazSherpa

    So we can say that a correlation of .63 is somewhere between moderate and strong, fair? And, that's just looking at daily volume. So, I will repeat my initial observation. If you have something with a high degree of correlation to range and you're looking for continuation - that's one variable that you might want to take into consideration.
     
    #34     Aug 14, 2021
  5. SunTrader

    SunTrader

    Vince who the fack is dat?

    You can calculate 20 years of whatever you like. I've got 20+ years of trading experience minute by minute watching, staring, trading .... the markets.
     
    #35     Aug 14, 2021
  6. userque

    userque

    That's fair, but brings us back to my original concern.

    Your calculation is looking at the correlation for the same day. Another way of asking my question:

    At the close, I see volume is up. So, that means it's likely that today's range was wide. I check, yup, it was. But I could have known that by just looking at the range in the first place.

    So how would a correlation, on daily data, between variables on the same day, indicate something about the future?

    I'm going to rerun the correlation on spy. But instead of checking it between today's range and volume, I'm going to check it between today's volume and TOMORROW'S range. Be right back.
     
    #36     Aug 14, 2021
  7. NazSherpa

    NazSherpa

    I ran it for the entire data set that I had available. I'll go with the larger data set, thank you. I'm illustrating that there is a correlation between volume and range. It's one variable that goes into determining the likelihood of a given type of day. If you don't find it useful - don't use it.

    A correlation of even .40 in the world of trading is worth paying attention to, IMO
     
    #37     Aug 14, 2021
  8. userque

    userque

    On SPY daily, from 1993, correlation between today's volume and TOMORROW'S range is, of course, worse at: 0.343818513
     
    #38     Aug 14, 2021
  9. NazSherpa

    NazSherpa

    I've been trading since '93. Full time since '98, so I guess I've got a year or two on you.
     
    #39     Aug 14, 2021
  10. userque

    userque

    I'm curious, run it against the NEXT DAY range, like I just did, and see what you get.
     
    #40     Aug 14, 2021