What was your position yesterday, was the S&P up or down, were you up or down? I have the impression you were down on Monday as well, but I am not sure.
I think it is you who is missing the point. Given your STD, I could just leverage the SPY (1.4) to get same STD as yours, BUT the return would be 1.4 performance of SPY. 1.4 SPY was around 45% this year. The results should be normalized. It is the ratio of return divided by STD that matters. Anyone could beat the SPY if variance were not an issue.
Here's a performance update: (there was a slight change on the sharpe ratio calculation that is now based on annualized performance instead of cumulative performance) <table class="google-visualization-table-table" cellspacing="0" style="width: 260px; "><tbody><tr class="google-visualization-table-tr-head"><td class="google-visualization-table-th google-visualization-table-sorthdr"><span class="google-visualization-table-sortind"> </span></td><td class="google-visualization-table-th google-visualization-table-sorthdr">TGA<span class="google-visualization-table-sortind"> </span></td><td class="google-visualization-table-th google-visualization-table-sorthdr">S&P<span class="google-visualization-table-sortind"> </span></td></tr><tr class="google-visualization-table-tr-even"><td class="google-visualization-table-td">YTD </td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">-1,45%</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">-0,32%</td></tr><tr class="google-visualization-table-tr-odd"><td class="google-visualization-table-td">Cum Perf</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">13,16%</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">18,99%</td></tr><tr class="google-visualization-table-tr-odd"><td class="google-visualization-table-td">StdDev</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">15,12%</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">11,28%</td></tr><tr class="google-visualization-table-tr-odd"><td class="google-visualization-table-td">Sharpe R.</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">1,11</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">1,34</td></tr><tr class="google-visualization-table-tr-odd"><td class="google-visualization-table-td">Avg Perf</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">0,06%</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">0,09%</td></tr><tr class="google-visualization-table-tr-even"><td class="google-visualization-table-td">Avg W</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">0,67%</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">0,56%</td></tr><tr class="google-visualization-table-tr-odd"><td class="google-visualization-table-td">Avg L</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">-0,65%</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">-0,54%</td></tr><tr class="google-visualization-table-tr-even"><td class="google-visualization-table-td"># W</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">111</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">117</td></tr><tr class="google-visualization-table-tr-odd"><td class="google-visualization-table-td"># L</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">95</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">89</td></tr><tr class="google-visualization-table-tr-odd"><td class="google-visualization-table-td">Max DD</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">-6,96%</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">-5,76%</td></tr><tr class="google-visualization-table-tr-odd"><td class="google-visualization-table-td">Curr DD</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">-5,29%</td><td class="google-visualization-table-td google-visualization-table-td-number">-0,32%</td></tr></tbody></table>