The CL/NQ experiment

Discussion in 'Journals' started by Gabe2004, Nov 20, 2013.

  1. Candle based.
    The MA's are there just to keep me in the right direction overall but sometimes I would go against them if the bar patterns tells me to.

    Gabe
     
    #241     Jan 18, 2014
  2. Is it a different trading system ?
     
    #242     Jan 18, 2014
  3. My entries and exits are strictly candle based.
    During the day I hardly notice that the MAs are there.
    I may take them off or use the shorter one to keep me in trades longer.
    The benefit is yet to be investigated.

    Gabe
     
    #243     Jan 18, 2014
  4. I would say that I have only 1 system with several "if then" variants.

    Gabe
     
    #244     Jan 18, 2014
  5. Is it possible for you to trade just the exact same way :
    for instance
    if you use ma, you use them for all trades, no exception?
     
    #245     Jan 18, 2014
  6. That is the general idea.
    Regarding my trades on Friday I would say that all my entries were by my rules except for 1 where I missed the entry so I entered a few ticks away from my desired entry point.
    The problem was that I ignored S/R zones.
    Next week I will use a modified rule base.
    I believe that I will get to a conclusion with very few iterations.
    With that said (written), it is possible that during certain times the outcome of trades will be negative even if rules were followed.

    Gabe
     
    #246     Jan 18, 2014
  7. I'm not sure trading multiple cars makes it easier. More decisions to be made re: when to exit and without consistency the drawdowns with several cars could be discouraging. I'll only consider scaling out once I get a consistent win rate. Not saying I'm right just my .02.
     
    #247     Jan 18, 2014
  8. I don't want to be rude, but what exactly is the point of this thread? Obviously, a lot of people are following it intently, so I am clearly missing something. An unprofitable trader with a mystery method and people can't seem to get enough of it?

    Is this an automated system or is it manual? I ask because there were apparently 10 trades on Friday. Most of the trades I looked at appeared more or less random, which is why I asked about the logic. Maybe you have a great system and can trade that frequently, but my experience has been that it won't work.
     
    #248     Jan 18, 2014
  9. His page rocketed after :
    "-"boredom... not by my rules"
    -"I was trading as if I was possessed"
    -"I traded like a maniac"
    -"external influences but I should have realized them and not trade"
    -"go after big move-lose. I nibble, I do fine"
    -"maximum day loss"
    -"swinging between periods of full discipline to no discipline at all"
    -"turned a good day into a bad day"
    -"have one trade still on. Reluctant to end the day on the negative side.
    Looks like the trade turned into an investment"
    -"I am short and should have been out a long time ago"
    -"broke rules today"
    -"examples of how NOT to trade"
    -"another disastrous day for me. Perhaps I should keep my day job.
    The problem is I don't have a day job
    ".
    -"follow rules, something happens and I break all rules"
    -"kept a loser for far too long"
    -"bad with respect to following the plan and the rules"
    -"LUCK OR EDGE?"
    -"almost there"
    -"chickened out"
    "

    In which journal a trader has shown so much self-honesty ?
     
    #249     Jan 18, 2014
  10. slugar

    slugar

    maybe he is writing in a journal to get help from more experienced traders
     
    #250     Jan 18, 2014