Hi Joab, Do you mind elaborating? <p> Are you serious about the 10% monthly (200+% p.a.) bit? If so what kind of leverage are we talking?
Current Team <p><p>ERIC<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 29.93<br>Date: 07/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 31.43<br>Qty: 300<br>Cost: $8,979.00<p>LCAV<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 17.48<br>Date: 08/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 18.35<br>Qty: 600<br>Cost: $10,488.00<p>ALTR<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 18.66<br>Date: 09/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 19.82<br>Qty: 250<br>Cost: $4,665.00<p>XLNX<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 22.83<br>Date: 09/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 24.74<br>Qty: 200<br>Cost: $4,566.00<p>NDAQ<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 41.83<br>Date: 13/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 37.96<br>Qty: 470<br>Cost: $19,660.10<p>SYNA<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 55.60<br>Date: 13/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 50.51<br>Qty: 360<br>Cost: $20,016.00<p>AG<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 59.36<br>Date: 14/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 55.20<br>Qty: 330<br>Cost: $19,588.80<p>MTG<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 23.01<br>Date: 15/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 25.33<br>Qty: 210<br>Cost: $4,832.10<p>MER<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 56.67<br>Date: 15/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 62.35<br>Qty: 90<br>Cost: $5,100.30<p>
Ex Players <p><p>CIEN<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 45.33<br>Date: 13/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 42.54<br>Qty: 440<br>Cost: $19,945.20<br>Exit: 42.54<br>Date: 19/11/2007<br>Return (pts): -2.79<br>Return (%): -6.15%<br>Return ($): -$1,227.60<p>AIZ<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 64.75<br>Date: 12/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 60.99<br>Qty: 300<br>Cost: $19,425.00<br>Exit: 64.22<br>Date: 14/11/2007<br>Return (pts): -0.53<br>Return (%): -0.82%<br>Return ($): -$159.00<p>MLNM<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 13.90<br>Date: 13/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 12.67<br>Qty: 1400<br>Cost: $19,460.00<br>Exit: 14.02<br>Date: 14/11/2007<br>Return (pts): 0.12<br>Return (%): 0.86%<br>Return ($): $168.00<p>JEF<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 23.67<br>Date: 13/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 25.39<br>Qty: 210<br>Cost: $4,970.70<br>Exit: 25.39<br>Date: 14/11/2007<br>Return (pts): -1.72<br>Return (%): -7.27%<br>Return ($): -$361.20<p>TKC<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 23.93<br>Date: 08/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 22.73<br>Qty: 830<br>Cost: $19,861.90<br>Exit: 25.46<br>Date: 13/11/2007<br>Return (pts): 1.53<br>Return (%): 6.39%<br>Return ($): $1,269.90<p>CIEN<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 47.07<br>Date: 05/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 44.24<br>Qty: 350<br>Cost: $16,474.50<br>Exit: 44.24<br>Date: 09/11/2007<br>Return (pts): -2.83<br>Return (%): -6.01%<br>Return ($): -$990.50<p>MON<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 94.38<br>Date: 06/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 89.66<br>Qty: 210<br>Cost: $19,820.46<br>Exit: 96.73<br>Date: 09/11/2007<br>Return (pts): 2.35<br>Return (%): 2.49%<br>Return ($): $492.84<p>MTG<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 19.21<br>Date: 08/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 20.17<br>Qty: 550<br>Cost: $10,565.50<br>Exit: 20.17<br>Date: 09/11/2007<br>Return (pts): -0.96<br>Return (%): -5.00%<br>Return ($): -$528.00<p>MOS<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 69.03<br>Date: 06/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 65.58<br>Qty: 280<br>Cost: $19,329.46<br>Exit: 71.09<br>Date: 08/11/2007<br>Return (pts): 2.06<br>Return (%): 2.98%<br>Return ($): $575.74<p>IBKR<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 29.15<br>Date: 05/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 26.23<br>Qty: 340<br>Cost: $9,911.00<br>Exit: 28.99<br>Date: 06/11/2007<br>Return (pts): -0.16<br>Return (%): -0.55%<br>Return ($): -$54.40<p>
Current Bench <p><p>BMC<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 33.33<br>Date: 13/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 31.46<p>SOHU<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 52.12<br>Date: 13/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 46.88<p>TGIC<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 9.32<br>Date: 15/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 10.27<p>AG<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 58.59<br>Date: 20/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 55.19<p>
Ex Benchers <p><p>BGC<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 72.12<br>Date: 14/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 66.99<br>Exit: 66.99<br>Date: 21/11/2007<br>Return (pts): -5.13<br>Return (%): -7.11%<p>ZRAN<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 23.38<br>Date: 14/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 21.99<br>Exit: 21.99<br>Date: 21/11/2007<br>Return (pts): -1.39<br>Return (%): -5.95%<p>ODP<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 19.27<br>Date: 15/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 20.51<br>Exit: 16.72<br>Date: 21/11/2007<br>Return (pts): 2.55<br>Return (%): 13.23%<p>CKFR<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 47.53<br>Date: 13/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 45.10<br>Exit: 47.49<br>Date: 20/11/2007<br>Return (pts): -0.04<br>Return (%): -0.08%<p>FWLT<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 144.45<br>Date: 14/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 129.98<br>Exit: 129.98<br>Date: 20/11/2007<br>Return (pts): -14.47<br>Return (%): -10.02%<p>CY<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 34.00<br>Date: 14/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 30.59<br>Exit: 30.59<br>Date: 20/11/2007<br>Return (pts): -3.41<br>Return (%): -10.03%<p>CCRT<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 13.29<br>Date: 15/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 14.63<br>Exit: 12.42<br>Date: 20/11/2007<br>Return (pts): 0.87<br>Return (%): 6.55%<p>MS<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 54.72<br>Date: 15/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 59.23<br>Exit: 50.36<br>Date: 20/11/2007<br>Return (pts): 4.36<br>Return (%): 7.97%<p>ABK<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 29.69<br>Date: 15/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 32.67<br>Exit: 24.90<br>Date: 20/11/2007<br>Return (pts): 4.79<br>Return (%): 16.13%<p>ACF<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 11.89<br>Date: 15/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 13.09<br>Exit: 10.41<br>Date: 19/11/2007<br>Return (pts): 1.48<br>Return (%): 12.45%<p>LEN<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 20.61<br>Date: 15/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 22.68<br>Exit: 17.60<br>Date: 19/11/2007<br>Return (pts): 3.01<br>Return (%): 14.60%<p>RAD<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 3.70<br>Date: 15/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 3.97<br>Exit: 3.53<br>Date: 19/11/2007<br>Return (pts): 0.17<br>Return (%): 4.59%<p>NTRI<br>Drtn: Short<br>Entry: 24.30<br>Date: 15/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 26.74<br>Exit: 23.33<br>Date: 16/11/2007<br>Return (pts): 0.97<br>Return (%): 3.99%<p>OI<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 45.24<br>Date: 16/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 42.88<br>Exit: 42.88<br>Date: 16/11/2007<br>Return (pts): -2.36<br>Return (%): -5.22%<p>TX<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 36.22<br>Date: 06/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 34.40<br>Exit: 38.00<br>Date: 09/11/2007<br>Return (pts): 1.78<br>Return (%): 4.91%<p>KLBAY<br>Drtn: Long<br>Entry: 41.10<br>Date: 06/11/2007<br>Disaster Stop: 39.04<br>Exit: 41.00<br>Date: 07/11/2007<br>Return (pts): -0.10<br>Return (%): -0.24%<p>
Yes, I am serious ! Use 2:1 leverage starting with 500k and see IF you can get that return never risking more then 5% max per trade. If you can post your fills as soon as you can that would be great.
A lot of the 'experts' advise that it is not prudent to risk more than 2% on any trade. Infact, I have read that professional traders often risk much less than 1% per trade. I am sticking to the 2% guideline, at the moment. However, my gut instinct is that 5% is an acceptable risk for small accounts IF and ONLY IF a system with a quantifiable edge and low historical drawdowns is being employed. I know that acrary has a thread on position sizing with some very interesting and original ideas. From what I remember, the thread suggests it is ok to risk more than 2% depending on the performance characteristics of the system employed. I intend to study acrary's position sizing ideas in the near future and see if I can incorporate them in FAB TEAM. Even if I do decide to risk more than 2%, I will still be limited by the amount of capital available, unless I significantly reduce my stop sizes and/or the number of stocks I trade at a time. My model allows me to have 10 or more open positions, which means I can not allocate (assuming 2:1 leverage) more than 20% (it can even be as low as 5% when I have more than 10 open positions) of my capital to one position. Sometimes, this means that I am compelled to risk less than 2% of my capital on a particular position. Having said that, I believe this obstacle can be overcome with the intelligent use of options. It is one avenue I am keen to pursue, particularly since I will be able to apply some of the stuff I learnt on the CQF. Joab, what are your views on the 2% risk guideline?
Your correct 2% is the industry standard so to speak BUT in my experiences I have found that with no more then 20 positions (at one time) and with accounts under 5 million and highly liquid stocks (as yours seem to be) then 5% is the ONLY way that you can consistently produce returns in excess of 10% per month. I currently manage 5 million now (up from 2 million) and it is getting more and more difficult to maintain these returns. The biggest problem is not size but rather asset. Just because a stock has the correct edge technically speaking doesn't mean it's trade worthy.
Assuming you allocate equal capital to each position, I don't see how you can have as many as 20 open positions and still risk up to 5% per position. For a 5m account with 20 equally funded positions and assuming 2:1 leverage: Capital for each position = 5m x 2/20 = 500,000 5% risk = 5/100 x 5m = 250,000 To calculate risk in each position (i.e stop size) = 250,000/500,00 = 50% In other words, to risk 5% when you have 20 positions you will need to have a 50% stop. Is this how you go about it, or am I just being dense?
I thought when they talk about 2% or 5% risk they mean 2% or 5% of the value of that position and not the value of the account. So for a 5 million account with 2:1 leverage and 20 equal positions, 5% risk would be 5% of 500,000= $25000. Since you are using leverage of 2, from $500,000 in each position, only 250,000 is yours. So 5% of each position would be only $12500 !!