There is no conflict, successful methods are kept secret for obvious reasons and unsuccessful ones are hawked for equally obvious reasons
I was in the room for a few days until I simply couldn't take it anymore. I had to scream "uncle". The moderator Charles Cochran simply refuses to call any real trades in real time. All his shit is "woulda coulda shoulda"...He's a woulda coulda shoulda TEACHER, just like all the others. I was expecting to at least see him demonstrate his system with his REAL money on the line. I would be willing to bet my ass that he can't trade the system profitably.
Your statement can't be any further from the truth. Market Profile was purchased by the Chicago Board of Trade from Peter Steidlymayer to provide the global trading community a proven and successful methodology. Peter Steidlymayer did just the opposite of what you state. He offered a 'secret' successful methodology to benefit many, many traders. BTW......I clerked for Pete Steidymayer in the late '70's. I know first hand how successful he was. He is the most unselfish person I know. He'd like every small independent trader to succeed. Some of you think that the sharing of ideas is hawkish. We think the sharing of ideas (for a fee) is a noble and just enterprise. It is up to the marketplace to determine the value of our ideas.
Nup.. none of you guys will ever be able to answer the question "Why don't you trade it yourself? why do you need my money if it is successful?" And before you bother I've heard em all.. and none of them can circumvent that very simple truth
We do reveal proper trade location all throughout the day. I doubt you were in the traders room for a few days because typically in "a few days" there would have been at least 10 or 12 trades to execute, if not more. There is no 'follow the leader' methodology in our trader room. Just wonderring: do any of you know of a successful follow the leader program? We teach you to trade. We help you to learn.
Well that's really the problem isn't it If you could trade you'd be able to make so much more than what you can from subscriptions Traders love trading... Salesmen love selling The logic has always been inescapable
And vice versa, all the unsuccesful traders and chatrooms that I know also refuse to demonstrate that they can, themselves, trade the shit their pushing. Hell, trade on a simulator for all I care, but at least demonstrate that you can trade your own system.
Once again, there is no such thing as a successful 'system'. There are good methodologies and bad methodologies. Communicating trade ideas, market concepts, execution methodologies and trade management is a far cry from "pushing' a system" as you so elequently state.
Call it a system, methodology, or Winnebago for all I care...you know the point I was trying to drive home. Why should I fork over $400 per month to you if you can't demonstrate that you can 'trade'?