Teaching Candidates Aplenty, but the Jobs Are Few

Discussion in 'Wall St. News' started by hoffmanw, May 19, 2010.

  1. Teaching Candidates Aplenty, but the Jobs Are Few
    Published: May 19, 2010

    PELHAM, N.Y. — In the month since Pelham Memorial High School in Westchester County advertised seven teaching jobs, it has been flooded with 3,010 applications from candidates as far away as Colorado and California. The Port Washington district on Long Island is sorting through 3,620 applications for eight positions — the largest pool the superintendent has seen in his 41-year career.

    Even hard-to-fill specialties are no longer so hard to fill. Jericho, N.Y., has 963 people to choose from for five spots in special education, more than twice as many as in past years. In Connecticut, chemistry and physics jobs in Hartford that normally attract no more than five candidates have 110 and 51, respectively.

    The recession seems to have penetrated a profession long seen as recession-proof: superintendents, education professors and job-seekers say that teachers are facing the worst job market since the Great Depression. Amid state and local budget cuts, cash-poor urban districts like New York City and Los Angeles, which used to hire thousands of young people every spring, have taken down the help wanted signs.

    Even upscale suburban districts are bracing for huge levels of layoffs — school officials and union leaders estimate than more than 150,000 teachers nationwide could lose their jobs next year, far more than any other time, including the last major financial crisis of the 1970s.

    Juliana Pankow, who just graduated from Teachers College at Columbia University, has sent out 40 résumés since January. A few Saturdays ago, she showed up at a Harlem school because she heard the principal would be there (she was invited back to teach a demonstration lesson, but it may be for naught since the city has a hiring freeze). Now, Ms. Pankow said she may have to move back in with her parents in Scarsdale, N.Y., and perhaps take up SAT tutoring.

    “I can’t think of anything else I’d rather do,” said Ms. Pankow, 23, as she waited outside the Pelham principal’s office last week, one of 619 people applying for one English position. “Which is a problem, because I might have to do something else.”

    At Teachers College, so many students like Ms. Pankow are looking for work that two recent job fairs attracted a record 650 students and alumni, up from 450 last year. And last month, the college added a new job fair focusing on Harlem schools.

    But job postings are down by half this year, to between one and two dozen a week — mostly in charter schools, according to Marianne Tramelli, the college’s director of career services.

    Charter schools, which are publicly financed but independently run, are practically the only ones hiring in New York and elsewhere, because of growing enrollments amid expanding political and economic support for school choice. Even so, they do not have nearly enough jobs to go around.

    In New York, where the Success Charter Network is hiring 135 new teachers for its seven schools in Harlem and the Bronx, some of the 8,453 applicants have called the office three times a day to check on their status. Veteran teachers have also offered to work as assistant teachers.

    “It’s heartbreaking — there’s much more desperation out there,” said Eva S. Moskowitz, a former city councilwoman who is the network’s founder and chief executive.

    KIPP, another charter school network with 82 schools nationwide, has received 745 applications since January at its seven schools in the San Francisco Bay Area, compared with 385 last year.

    At the University of Pennsylvania, most of the 90 new teachers who graduated last weekend are still jobless. Many had counted on offers from the Philadelphia public schools, but had their interviews canceled this month after the district announced a hiring freeze.

    “We’re trying to encourage everyone to hold on,” said Kathy Schultz, an education professor at Penn. “But that’s very difficult because students have taken out loans and want to be assured of a job.”

    Michigan State University has pushed its 500 graduating teachers to look out of state. As local jobs have dried up, it started an internship program in Chicago, which is a four-hour drive from the East Lansing, Mich., campus. Professors now go with students to the annual campus job fair to make sure they do not hover around the Michigan tables, but walk over to, say, North Carolina, Virginia or Texas.

    “We have a culture of people wanting to stay here and teach where they went to school, but we also want them to get jobs,” said Suzanne Wilson, chairwoman of the Department of Teacher Education.

    Jade Stier, 27, finally gave up and enrolled in a nursing program last fall — along with five other former teachers — after three years of looking for an elementary school job. She sent out hundreds of résumés, only to land one interview a year. She settled for working as a substitute teacher, earning $85 a day with no benefits.

    “Spending $50,000 for an education you can’t use is really frustrating,” she said. “I definitely miss teaching, but I felt like I had no other choice. I had to just move on.”

    If there is an upside to the shortage of teaching jobs, it is that schools now have their pick of candidates.

    Teach for America, which places graduates from some of the nation’s top colleges in poor schools, has seen applications increase by nearly a third this year to 46,000 — for 4,500 slots. From Ivy League colleges alone, there are 1,688 would-be teachers.

    Here in Pelham, a well-regarded district where teaching salaries range from $50,000 to $134,000, high school administrators and teachers have spent the past three weeks winnowing résumés. Candidates with grade-point averages below 3.0 were eliminated (3.3 in some departments), as were those who missed the April 30 application deadline. Almost 200 were invited for interviews.

    “It’s very difficult,” said Jeannine Clark, the high school principal in Pelham. “More so than in years past because there are so many very qualified candidates.”

    While Ms. Clark and the English supervisor were meeting with prospective teachers last week, candidates for the social studies job were down the hallway typing a 40-minute timed essay on the French Revolution. Upstairs, interviews for physics and biology teachers were being conducted.

    “People will come in here begging for anything,” said Dennis R. Lauro Jr., the superintendent, who started closing his office door this year because out-of-work teachers would drop in unannounced to hand him résumés. “We’ve never seen these kinds of numbers before.”

    Top candidates will be asked to return several more times to meet with Dr. Lauro, parents and students and teach a demonstration class.

    Ms. Pankow is hoping she will be among them.

    “It would be unbelievable,” she said. “I would love it here, but I’m not necessarily putting all my eggs in this basket.”

  2. Those who can, do.
    Those who cannot, teach.
  3. And those who can't teach, teach gym.
  4. ipatent


    The problem is that the system favors applicants with "education credentials," which creates a barrier to entry for people who have more to offer. The typical HS teacher was a middling student himself and is not that intelligent. There are lawyers, engineers and even doctors out there who have made their stash and would love to escape the rat race and get summers off.
  5. S2007S


    I recall a long time ago hearing that teaching was a recession proof job, who ever believed that one to be true is a damn fool.
  6. Why would teaching be a recession proof job? Any profession is subject to having more candidates than positions. Supply and demand.

    Get a job in the welfare office. When things get tough, welfare ranks swell and they need more people to give away my money..
  7. I noticed in the article is these pikers are looking for elementary school jobs. In other words, these people are morons to being with.

    Back in the fall, I ran into a physics professor who said that there are high schools in NJ giving $10k signing bonus for physics teachers.

    There is a need for the math and science, and probably not much else.
  8. Math and science teaching jobs were outsourced to India.
  9. pitz


    Been no different for engineers in the past decade, particularly, in IT.

    Typical 'good' IT job gets 1000 applicants per position.