Tastytrade Review + Criticism

Discussion in 'Options' started by Lucas, May 27, 2015.

  1. xandman

    xandman

    Given how the skew was before the pop, she must have been writing a lot of contracts.
     
    #91     Aug 24, 2015
  2. RedDuke

    RedDuke

    Interesting how she fared last week. Btw, I could not find her performance posted anywhere officially.
     
    #92     Aug 31, 2015
  3. Daal

    Daal

    From the way she sounded in her 2014 interview, I'd be shocked if she didn't lose big last month.
     
    #93     Sep 11, 2015
  4. RedDuke

    RedDuke

    Does her fund post performance anywhere?
     
    #94     Sep 14, 2015
  5. Alex27

    Alex27

    She's sharp she would have a plan in place and hedged or got out
     
    #95     Sep 14, 2015
  6. RedDuke

    RedDuke

    Selling for premium is really hard to hedge especially with VIX over 50. Anyone knows the name of her fund? I can look at few databases.
     
    #96     Sep 14, 2015
  7. emg

    emg


    The idea of tasty trade is for new small traders to open account with TD Ameritrade aka think or swim. Therefore, tastytrade is for small traders entertainment tonight and helps 3rd party educational service to increase their business.


    More than 90% of small traders lose! They just lose!
     
    #97     Sep 14, 2015
  8. TD80

    TD80

    Just Hope Hedge Fund

    I suspect she is (relatively speaking) just fine with this last move.

    I suspect if S&P pulled a 1987 (I know, I know, curbs/limits now blah blah blah, just see Fukushima please or any other crazy outlier event where the market will wait out limit timeframes/closures and still keep crashing), then she would be out of business.

    The problem is that she needs liquidity and in the short premium market getting liquidity for a billion $+ book (given leverage) is not so easy as say, underlying futures trading. I think it is much better suited to 7 figure accounts or smaller...

    The lack of deeply liquid option instrument choices means that once you get to a certain size, you either diversify away from her type of strategy or one day you go bust trying to meet return expectations...

    This brings back the old adage, you never want to be the market, especially if you have leverage on (and thus can be forced to liquidate).

     
    #98     Sep 14, 2015
  9. Chubbly

    Chubbly

    Has TT ever mentioned her since the Aug 24 mini-crash? I was curious as I don't watch the show. She may have been smart enough to be hedged but I assume many of her followers were not
     
    #99     Nov 23, 2015
  10. Events like August of 2015 won't do that much damage to her strategy. She's already stated in all her interviews that when faced with significant drawdowns, she just rolls them out to further months and doubles down on her put selling.

    So for August, she would have rolled to October and sold twice as many puts. Things recovered, so she would have survived just fine.

    The time when Karen and all her clients will lose everything will be something more similar to a 2008 event. She rolls out, doubles down, and it goes further against her. She rolls out, doubles down, and it goes further against her.

    That will be the end of Karen. 7 great years followed by an OH THAT'S WHY my strategy was crappy.... :)
     
    #100     Nov 24, 2015