I take it this is not your day job? Because if you trade for a living, you cannot survive by simply beating the s&p 500. Those guys that you mention that under perform the s&p 500 have one thing you don't have, a management fee. If this is not your day job then fine, I guess whatever return satisfies you is all that matters. But the title of your thread is a little misleading. This is far from a holy grail.
I think there may be some confusion about my goal. Yes, I consider it a win at THIS stage if I am simply beating the S&P. At this stage, I am only taking long trades and entering the market at what likely may be the top for the year. Beating the overall market is a win. As I continue this journal, simply beating the S&P is not the goal. I believe the title of this thread when I say "Swing Trading is the Holy Grail". I believe the method I am trading, and the overall strategy is the key to successful trading. Leaving the micro time frames and moving to approx 5 day holding periods is more lucrative. Especially when every trade signal I take I KNOW is tilted in my direction based on the data mining I have conducted. Moving forward, I will continue to add new sub strategies to the overall strategy while I adapt to trading this method live. Starting today, I am now also generating short trades. The overall shorting strategy is not complete. It will evolve over time as I continue to add more patterns, but its sufficient as a starting point to go with the long strategies.
Tomorrow I am watching the following: Longs - AET,KO,NTAP Shorts- txn,wag,mdp More info: <a href="http://www.mystockanalysis.com">Watch List</a>
I think you have a good strategy, based on your latest long watch list. I've tested this same strategy and it works best in a bullish general market. I would strongly suggest switching the signal around to the short side if the market turns! I like using a 10 EMA on the SPY for my market direction indicator.
Lots of trades so far today: Purchased 53 shares of FAST @$48.63 stop @$47.70 purchased 78 shares of NTAP @$40.33 stop $39.69 Shorted 86 shares of MDT at $37.92 stop $38.51 Shorted 142 shares of MU at 7.19 stop 7.75
More than a month since last update. No update on blog for 2 weeks. I guess Swing Trading is NOT the Holy Grail.