I remember all your posts... even the AMZN short when everyone was bullish at the time. I keep track of stock picks. Whatever you do works. One of the best track records here since I've been around. Wonder what ever happened to poor Haji. CAT, 3M, and HD must have shut him down.
If you mean Mr surf, well, I do not consider him to be silly. He might be lacking knowledge in certain areas of trading, namely short term trading, but to those who know, he has actually demonstrated his knowledge of investing, which is actually quite good. Calls mean nothing, do not be fooled by that. What matters most is what is said "between the lines".
I will take a bet that Mr surf can produce a screenshot of actual trade account showing a positive return over a 1 year period.