Spydertrader's Jack Hershey Futures Trading Journal

Discussion in 'Journals' started by Spydertrader, Dec 30, 2006.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Spyder,

    Could we maybe get more indepth on the YM and its use as a leading indicator? The month is halfway through, and I dont know if we discussed it ad nauseum yet :)

    Does anyone agree or disagree?
     
    #1191     Feb 16, 2007
  2. Very NICE... You really get the hang of this... I think that in order to ease alot of nerves around here, we should probably get into a channel of channels discussion with the encapsulatING channel being the forest and the encapsulatED channel keeping folks busy. On your chart, you show the encapsulatING channel. The traverses and retraces are the encapsulatED channel. If all this is still causing issues for folks, I'll have to take a tangent elsewhere and do the one point a day type of setup dea that is a near replica of equities...

    Regards,
    MAK
     
    #1192     Feb 16, 2007
  3. Jander

    Jander

    that would be excellent mak..

    by the way, is it me or have there been a hell of alot of flaws today?
     
    #1193     Feb 16, 2007
  4. jbarnby

    jbarnby

    This is my 5th day plotting channels as I was late to discover this thread. I've read most of the material and intend to read everything again this weekend. My biggest hurdle has been in recognizing the pt 3 in real time. I hope that I will get a better feel for identifying these points after practicing for a few more weeks. Great thread and I'm learning a lot! This method feels very comfortable.

    John
     
    #1194     Feb 16, 2007
  5. There are at a sub forest view. I had been attempting to post ahead of time but by the time I was ready to hit submit, the move had already happened. My carryover on the YM was extended into today. I didn't need to update the extension. The question naturally would have been how did I know at the EOD of day yesterday that the last bar was a point3 and not and EOD effect... I would throw the experience card on the table but that's not a fair answer...

    Regards,
    MAK
     
    #1195     Feb 16, 2007
  6. The Gaussian no make sense to me, today we have R2R from 10:40-10:44 on YM. YM in down channel. I see R2R also on ES around same time. After this, price goes up. Can anyone explain?
     
    #1196     Feb 16, 2007
  7. ivob

    ivob

    Hi All,

    I find FTT's easy to recognize providing the channels are drawn in the right way.

    For example this morning see the attachment. In the first picture I use bars 3,4,5 to draw the channel. In the second picture I use bars 2,3,6 to draw the channel.

    Using the first picture one would recognize the FTT. In the second picture not. So my questions are:

    1. Should the channel be drawn as it is drawn in the first picture. Is that the correct way?
    2. If yes, why? It seems so logical to include bars 6 and 7 and I do recall Spyder stating that he is always looking to widen the channel. Or should both channels be drawn?

    regards,
    Ivo
     
    #1197     Feb 16, 2007
  8. nkhoi

    nkhoi

    carry over channel also give you FTT.
    ps. incase you wonder why I picked a down carry over channel, well, it open way down so it seem logical to pick that one, imho.
     
    #1198     Feb 16, 2007
  9. JDAndy

    JDAndy

    Spyder in the past has indicated that something like in your chart 2 would be a "taped FTT". Using a carry over from the downturn at the end of yesterday makes this FTT much more visible.
     
    #1199     Feb 16, 2007
  10. The carry over channel works great, only thing I see, and I may very well be wrong, is that there is no pt. 3. If you were to adjust it to have a pt 3, it would be a little steeper but fits nicely into todays action. Expanding that channel works great though, FTT very visable to me.

     
    #1200     Feb 16, 2007
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.