slippage at IDEALPRO

Discussion in 'Forex Brokers' started by KS96, Sep 26, 2007.

  1. KS96

    KS96

    USD/CAD sell stop @ 1.0062, filled @ 1.0055
    7 pips slippage at 10:04:45 CET on no news!

    Tight spreads my ass...
     
  2. pma

    pma

    Ouch KS! Sorry to hear that-time to switch brokers-have you tried trading currency futures on globex? Just trying to help-peace-
     
  3. fxpip

    fxpip

    Was this an entry order or closing one ?
     
  4. KS96

    KS96

    closing
     
  5. KS96

    KS96

    CS response unsatisfactory as usual:
    "There was a spike."
    Oh, yeah?? That's OK then...
     
  6. fxpip

    fxpip

    Was there some kind of acceleration ?
     
  7. joemiami

    joemiami Guest

    7 pips ?...that blows
     
  8. AC3

    AC3

    That blows..... not sure I read what the size was but as long as it was a dealable size then your owed a decent price .. I understand a point here point there but that is a tough obstacle to get around .....BTW a piece today in the WSJ re the spike in liquidity in cash fx ... given that info you would expect that tighter spreads would follow....
     
  9. KS96

    KS96

    More problems today:

    USD/HKD stop order at IDEALPRO (above the minimum size), executed at IDEAL at a rip off spread.

    Official answer:

    The order was executed at IDEAL because the price was better than IDEALPRO.
    (Again, there was a huge spike at the time of
    execution, which considered valid, and there
    was no specific reason given for it... according
    to the market-makers, the CR said.)

    Here we are talking about an execution of around 40-50 pips away from my stop-price.
     
  10. Steve_IB

    Steve_IB Interactive Brokers

    Stops use the bid/ask as the default. So if you had a sell stop in USD.CAD at 1.0062 then you would need to see the ask at our below 1.0062 in order for your stop to trigger. Then a market order is sent and you get filled on the bid.

    Check the attached time and sales. Ask is 1.0067 and then drops down to 1.0059. Normal market activity.
     
    #10     Sep 27, 2007