I think I actually said the similar thing about scalping earlier post so I assume that you aren't aware of it. And you have misunderstood what I was trying to say. You can achieve high PF by having high win rate low reward, or low win rate high reward or whatever. It's a matric of dollar return on per dollar invested. If you are scalping with extremely high win rate you can still achieve PF of 2, I just couldn't achieve that by scalping only the index. I am curious if any one get close to that result with scalping though.
thank you for a brilliant intuitive remark but i did say that it was once in a way so your comment shows extreme prejudice by the way 10 years statement also does not mean anything,in the trading world.
Not difficult with a history like yours. By the way, talking about brilliant remarks, I guess you missed the OP talking about consistency, not once in a way ...