With all my respect to you, VSTscalper, I write this to you and hope it won't get you mad like you did to Daniel.a. Thanks for posting you approach of trading, defining market conditions and the charts. It really helped me to get the ideas and focus on the simple things. But it seems like there is a frequent questions from the viewers including me. Again, watching chart doesn't mean that the executions were real. What people want to see is the proof. A slight piece of proof that your signals are profitable, not in the backtest but in the REAL live market where all bunch of HFTs are, where there is a possibility the market hits your limit order but won't get you filled. You keep saying that why is it so hard for people to acknowledge your algos don't need a backtest to prove its profitability, yet why is it so hard for you to understand without actual trading result, you can't claim that your algo is profitable. It seems like you are keep saying same things over and over again but there is a reason why people are asking you the same thing over and over again, the real result. The repertoires you give are just the same and repeats. Do you know how many people sent me a PM, telling me that every time when they asked for the real result, you just went away? All the net daily goals, or gotta go to drive, or go to shopping or those big money clients, etc doesn't makes your backtest result real nor proves your signal is profitable. Also, MC is faster than human trading decision yet you still don't go full auto??? You could watch over what it's been doing but putting order looking at the arrows????? You can say that it is your playground but what are the forums and communications for? Isn't it two way, back and forth, discussing? Probably I've seen all the post you posted on not only this forum but also the others as well. There is no way that you do not understand what the others(Daniel.a, Trader30, Simplemelike) are asking you for. You definitely know how to code, how to trade, how to backtest and what are the traps that you could possibly get while backtesting and forward-testing. But you keep avoiding revealing your backtest settings, which crucially affects the profitability, also haven't revealed the actual broker report or real time trading result. If the range bar is huge enough it doesn't really matter that much, but when you do the scalp, and the range bar is small, it is so important because when the market hits certain price doesn't mean your orders were filled. And I guarantee you already know these. Also, when the market moves super fast, possibility of your orders won't get filled might go up. Following your thread, watching your claims, I just wonder whats the hidden propaganda behind all these. Must be related to the money but who knows.
Good Morning VSTscalper, Thank you for showing: Few questions please: 1. Is this live real money trading results? 2. If the answer is No to the first question, please deposit $2000 in your account and trade the algo live real money on MES or MNQ for 1 month and post the results back here for all us traders to see for inspiration, so we can have some ideas on how to build our own algo for inspiration. If you do not have $2000, I will be the first to donate $100 to you just to see if your algo works live with real money. Thank you,
I was going to stay silent on this issue but after the recent posts in this thread, I thought it would be best to speak out. I leased algo from OP earlier this year and unfortunately the real time signals are very inaccurate. The signals come up very different in real time vs the strategy performance reports. For example, I would have real time losing signals and then if I reloaded that same chart, the chart would omit the failed trades. When I asked OP, he said there would be losers and he doesn’t take every trade. He then claimed he trades a certain way based off of support, resistance, etc…. However, I leased the algo with the understanding that it would be profitable from manually following the entry & exit signals. The strategy performance reports are a joke. I was a sucker and fell for it in zoom session because most trades worked considering its scalping and if you’re risking 50 ticks to make 4, etc… the odds are most trades will work. At the time, I didn’t know backtests could be painted. I thought would be best to just take a loss and move on but felt I should post after the recent activity in this thread. Hopefully this can prevent someone else from getting scammed. I have receipts but am not looking to get into a game of semantics. If anyone has any questions, feel free to PM. Cheers.
Interesting, as I believe he says any number of times in the thread he isn't selling anything, yet he did lease it to you. Hmmm
Good Morning VSTscalper, Questions please. 1. How much money are you clients making? 2. How can I see the annual reports of the clients making the money? 3. How can I join the clients making the money? 4. How much money can I buy your algos for? Thank you,
Could be the best way to sell a product. Nobody would sell/lease an automated system/algorithm which works well on liquid index futures. At least not cheap. The money is there in the markets and such a system would exploit that and scale to the maximum position size if it actually worked. So, if it’s for sale even for a modest sum the natural conclusion is that it doesn’t work sufficiently.
Hello Johnni.h, Thank you for coming forth about your experiences. Your comments help the trading community. It is damn shame how everyone takes advantage of retail traders. Trying to scam innocent people out of money. I am sorry you had to experience this. But there 1000s of more scammers, liars, and conmen out there too. Just a damn shame. smh. smh
You have literally called the OP a scammer. You say you have "receipts" but have not produced them. You, are also a scammer! I have no dog in this hunt... I don't care which way the tide breaks, or if the tide breaks at all. Like myself, VST is an ET old timer. And he too, is still in the game. It's interesting to me that most of the old timers that have been lionized in the Halls of ET are no longer seen. Most critics also end up gone, as their energy is spent on "proving" others wrong. When I fail, I fail MY way!
Hello tiddlywinks, If the OP provide memebers answer to the questions they are asking, then the scam stuff goes out the window. If OP do not want no problems, then OP need to stop posting SIM trades and post live trades if he serious about helping people. We here to make money, not be sold dreams.
Agreed. Let the OP answer these accusations first and give him the benefit of doubt for now. However, you have to admit that it does seem fishy. I don't see that being an 'old timer' should give anyone a free pass, nor serve as a guarantee that someone is still in the game. Anyone who's selling services/systems makes my alarm bells go off.