Standard vendor rebuff tactic - accuse anybody who calls vendors on their game a "loser trader". Bunch of vendors and their sock puppets on this thread.
I gotta chime in...I've read his book and to be honest it is like a horse tranquilizer. He does have a good grasp on PA and candlestick patterns, but any amount of time studying patterns will give any aspiring trader all the tutelage he or she needs. Maybe his videos offer more detailed info...I don't know. My guess is that only hours and hours of watching realtime data unfold will help you find the system that works for YOU. If a wildly successful ES trader gave me his system to execute, I guarantee I would screw it up bigtime.
If you do not believe price action trading can be taught then you do not know what price action trading is. Therefore, what we who do can see plainly is that you are one who doesn't. And yet you know so much that isn't so. I shall block you so as not to disrupt you reverie any more. His first book is an abomination and should never have been published without having gone under the knife of a sharp editor. But his video course is clear as a bell.