Robinhood Gets Almost Half Its Revenue in Controversial Bargain With High-Speed Traders

Discussion in 'Wall St. News' started by Humble Investor, Oct 15, 2018.

  1. Who said that they didn't. I was making a comparison to a traditional broker who charged commish.

    ES

     
    #11     Oct 16, 2018
  2. 777

    777

    And so you did, and I press Like on your reply!

    * at least one poster who I liked, Rin4et, was trying to trade through Robinhood so I go a little hard on them.

    No offence meant; I enjoy your posts.
     
    #12     Oct 18, 2018
  3. But seriously..what is wrong with this model? I do not trade stocks...but if I
    I were a passive investor I would seriously try them...

     
    #13     Oct 18, 2018
    trader99 likes this.
  4. Sig

    Sig

    Yes, most do. And most also charge commissions, so the percent of their revenue that they get from order flow is smaller than Robinhood, which doesn't charge commissions and thus obtains a mathematically larger percentage of their total revenue through payment for order flow. Even if they receive exactly the same or even less revenue on a dollar/share basis as other brokers. The hyperbolic headline is meant to exploit a kind of a blind spot human brains seem to have for percentages and what they actually represent.
     
    #14     Oct 19, 2018
  5. sss12

    sss12

    So if you are a passive investor you don't mind poor execution ? If you are using a standing limit order you are are going to get picked off...no matter what broker you are using. BUT, RH encourages this use, better flow to sell.
     
    #15     Oct 19, 2018
  6. So what are you saying? I get filled and Robinhood makes bank? Good!

    ES

     
    #16     Oct 19, 2018
  7. sss12

    sss12

    No, im saying you should have been filled at a better price. You got picked off. Not always but often....if you search this topic it was explained previously by others much better than I can. Btw...2 parties can not make bank on 1 trade.
     
    #17     Oct 19, 2018
    Cuddles likes this.
  8. I have never had a limit order fill at a better price at any broker...

    ES
     
    #18     Oct 19, 2018
  9. sss12

    sss12

    That is the point !! Guess it was not clear ! Don't use simple buy limits....which RH encourages because they sell the flow. (Obviously there are other types of limits but that is not this conv)
     
    #19     Oct 19, 2018
  10. What order type allows for price improvement? I am a full-Time trader in Spot Forex and a "Price Improvement" order type is not available. I have never received price improvement on any order type in Futures either.

    I think Traders in stocks can see several price quotes with different "paths" to take to get filled. How many times do traders miss their fill by going through a "path" that is not well chosen? Interactive Brokers has revolutionized this "path chosen" entry and exit method....but it has it's downfall also.

    Sometimes I buy the assortment at See's Candy rather than handpicking. But I am just a passive consumer of chocolates...not a connoisseur.

    ElectricThinksRobinhoodisGreatSavant

     
    Last edited: Oct 20, 2018
    #20     Oct 20, 2018