I wouldn't really call a 9.5% move on favorable earnings nuts. ($116 AH/ $106 close) It's definitely a wall street darling though. ... Checked the screen before I submit, now at $118.50. So 11.7% on earnings isn't THAT crazy... I'm going to hit submit now before I'm made a liar!
You problem is you're trying to understand the 'logic' behind it. Once you understand there is no logic behind it, you will understand better.
Well, assuming they heard that from the options traders, I guess now you know whether to believe what the options traders spread to the news.