Question to day traders: Which order types do you use on IBKR platform?

Discussion in 'Interactive Brokers' started by learner88, Oct 4, 2022.

  1. rb7

    rb7

    I've never found anything in IB regarding this.

    As for NT7, Why wouldn't we want the fill not being as realistic as possible?
     
    #11     Oct 5, 2022
  2. Overnight

    Overnight

    Well we do, of course! I was just suggesting that TWS might have that same option buried in it somewhere, where you can remove the whole top-of-book fakery.
     
    #12     Oct 5, 2022
  3. Bad_Badness

    Bad_Badness

    Hmm, with respect also, you could be right, but this article says "top of book". Of course things change. My personal experience seems to get "auto-magic" fills at the top of book.

    https://www.interactivebrokers.com/lib/cstools/faq/#/content/35807733

    Either way the OP can figure it out. It is just another tool that one needs to learn the limitations. :D
     
    #13     Oct 5, 2022
    rb7 likes this.
  4. mervyn

    mervyn

    limit order and profit target.
     
    #14     Oct 6, 2022
  5. rb7

    rb7

    "From top of the book", doesn't mean first in the queue.
    I've made intensive analysis of the way their simulation system works. I wanted to know how paper trading results could translate into real trading results. And I was surprised to see that LMT orders were put at the end of the queue, and stay there until it gets filled.

    Also, partial fills on Future instrument on paper trading, excluding the first fill, are not filled at the right price, something like 3.75 pts away from the market. The solution is to always use 1 as the qty. Anyways, I'm not sure how they manage volume based on the current bid/ask volume.
     
    #15     Oct 6, 2022
    Bad_Badness likes this.
  6. I use limit orders for longer-term trades. However, for day trades, I think market orders are better because day trading decisions need to be quickly executed.
     
    #16     Oct 7, 2022
  7. mervyn

    mervyn

    You trade futures, therefore your limit price is not far from the market, perhaps 1 to 2 points range.
     
    #17     Oct 7, 2022
  8. One question to the elitetraders who use market orders.

    When making a market order, is IBKR's adaptive algo order better than a simple, basic market order? When you choose IBalgo adaptive algo, do you choose urgent, normal or patient setting?

    IBKR's documentation on their adaptive algo orders sound more like marketing stuff which makes me a bit skeptical. It is more assuring to hear from the actual experience of elitetraders.
     
    #18     Oct 11, 2022
  9. largib

    largib

    This is something that has puzzled me:

    I have tested side by side for 3 months straight using tdAmeritrade API (market orders) and IB adaptive orders (with 'Normal' adaptivePriority) to buy a bunch stocks at about the same time and sell at about the same time.

    I have consistently gotten worse pricing in IB. I also tried IB MKT order straights, doesn’t seem to de better than TD also.

    I’m puzzled as TD is known to get paid for order flow so I would assume IB would get better prices (after commission). But that’s not the case in my experience.

    I really want to make IB work but the results are frustrating to me.

    I hope that I somehow did something obviously wrong and people here can share their experience!
     
    #19     Dec 8, 2022