Question for Grob/Hershey...

Discussion in 'Trading' started by makosgu, Sep 4, 2005.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Eagle8

    Eagle8

    This thread is absolutely great and has caused me to sign up to elite trader.
    please keep posting the examples and musings. I started off moderately unconvinced by the theory but am now following along with great interest and may well have to reread the whole thread from the start more carefully. In addition to the system there are other great ideas on the thread such as pushing bars from extreme right edge of screen etc. Mak's last post re gravity was particularly pertinent, I must lose my perpetual slight bearish bias induced by misplaced gravity analogy and may turn charts upside down for a bit.
    If you use ensign and are interested in prv you can set up a screen with constant volume bars with at the bottom bars showing the time each bar took to form - this might be useful in graphically showing volume momentum and I'll try to find the link. I believe you can also set up a study to graphically display bid/ask volume which might assist in dom analysis?

    As a random question and this may have been answered earlier in the thread is the length of a channel estimable in advance at all by either volatility/angle of channel/confluence with longer term channels? Having said this I understand you are using volume and volume momentum behaviour as the key indicator of possible channel change. Also none of your charts have macd or stoch indicators on them - do you think adding customised MACD (for strong vol/trend) and stoch (for range/low vol) to the mix moght be beneficial or just confusing.

    Anyway thanks for all the great posts.

    Eagle 8
     
    #251     Sep 13, 2005
  2. txuk

    txuk

    Still getting used to referencing by bar number... thanks for catching! I appreciate your encouragement... I'm learning more each day from you, Grob, and all of the other posters.
     
    #252     Sep 13, 2005
  3. I think friends/altar egos of Mr.Hershey should identify themselves.
     
    #253     Sep 13, 2005
  4. No Prob...

    Here's an a index chart that I keep up in the background to reference the bars. I just cross ref the min with the hour to quickly locate the bar index. If your excel savvy, you can DDE the time and rewrite the "Worksheet_Calculate" function to auto highlight the proper index (ie. range.cell.color.index=1 or something like that)...

    Kind Regards,
    MAK!
     
    #254     Sep 13, 2005
  5. Stalker

    Stalker

    Good luck in the afternoon, gotta go!
    tommorrow i will probably go out in the countryside to pick mushrooms, autumn in sweden, so you have to tame the beast without me!

    thanx to everyone,
    Stalker
     
    #255     Sep 13, 2005
  6. OT but FWIW, 20pts a day with 1 contract is the equivalent of my gross day's wage at my day job. This year is a bit diff since I went thru a handsome IPO. So you see how I am carving out the work ahead of me to get the job done.

    Thru bar 47... HO HUM... SOP. :cool:

    MAK!
     
    #256     Sep 13, 2005
  7. I guess you have not been reading Jacks post very long because if there are two things on this earth that I am sure of it is that there is no way in hell Jack could disquise his style for long and the other is that he would ever do it. He changed his handle twice for logistic reasons but he never made a secret of who it was.
     
    #257     Sep 13, 2005
  8. Stalker

    Stalker

    Oh no, I´m exposed...
    Wasn´t that eddie murphy movie from the eighties, Trading places, about futures trading?
    I might go undercover as "Inga from Sweden"...
     
    #258     Sep 13, 2005
  9. BA/Icarus/Grob... Is the following close to your str/squ values...

    http://www.indexarb.com/

    TIA
    MAK!

    Thru bar 55...
     
    #259     Sep 13, 2005
  10. WHOA... Is there news??? Had to wash and reverse as I held onto the 2M to continue the direction... Volume & tape at work again!

    Thru bar 58...

    MAK!
     
    #260     Sep 13, 2005
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.