I think they were splitting hairs when they closed your thread as you did qualify the difference from a previous thread. Anyhow Im answering your question because i think the moderator was a little too zealous. I think I have been in every major chat room out there. Some of them are run by very good traders but they invariably made money while I lost it and the same thing will happen to you if you go in for the calls. You may be able to follow calls on swing trades, I dont know, but the very short term stuff is entry critical and the lag, most of the time, will kill you. On the other hand I think you can learn if thats what you go in for. My advice would be to not try to trade if you do go in one. I am not going to reccommend one because I'm not qualified to judge them and I dont know what kind of person you are. If you are well disciplined and cautious you may benefit. If you are emotional and compulsive it will only cost you money.