Price/Volume Relationship

Discussion in 'Technical Analysis' started by bluedemon77, Jan 28, 2007.

  1. I have done some comparing too and find it pretty strange that many of my setups do not even show up on volume charts compared to a time chart of the same period. Different strokes.......
     
    #41     Jan 31, 2007
  2. Does anyone know how to calculate the vwap for ES futures using esignal?
     
    #42     Jan 31, 2007
  3. It took me 12 years to develop this approach so it isn't any wonder it isn't well known.
    I think it is possible with IQ feed. You need to check.
    The bottom indicator is an Ergodic Indicator. I use it only to confirm Trend and oscillations not to trade from.
    The yellow trend lines on the price portion of the chart are taken from the Prime Oscillations on the next fastest incremental chart (in this case the 343. And yes, I trade based solely on S/R, no averages (a variable), channels (a variable) or anything else. If it can't be used objectively I don't want it.
     
    #43     Jan 31, 2007
  4. Depends in part on how you're defining "low". You can always zoom in to a smaller interval in order to find a trade, but if volume is that low, then how attractive is the trade? In other words, the WRBs may look tempting, but if there is insufficient volume, will they meet your entry criteria?

    LC
     
    #44     Jan 31, 2007
  5. The only software I know that builds the bars correctly is Ensign and MultiCharts. I've been told that Sierra does but have been unable to verify that yet. You are correct. If the software doesn't cap the bars to the exact number of contracts or shares designatied per bar then then clarity the volume bars offer is rendered useless.

    Ensign is a pain to use because of the "refresh" feature.
     
    #45     Jan 31, 2007
  6. If you read the thread I linked it will answer a lot of questions. I think I covered everything there. Sorry but there is a lot of information in that thread and repeating it would make my hand hurt . . . lol
     
    #46     Jan 31, 2007
  7. You are absolutely correct about them filtering out the noise. They are perfect for that. But remember because they are constant (at least Ensign & MultiCharts bars) they are uneffected by spikes in volume on extreme tops or bottoms they simple move faster . . . without the noise. In low volume times they simply move slower . . . without the noise but in either case their movement is consistent. Trends exist one chart increment at a time. If you "Zoom in" on a chart you are rendering the trend on that chart useless become you have MOVED the chart increment to a faster oscillation.
     
    #47     Jan 31, 2007
  8. skippy

    skippy



    Any knowledge of TradeStation's CVBs? Does TS cap at the number of contracts specified? Thanks...
     
    #48     Jan 31, 2007
  9. skippy

    skippy


    Actually, to hazard an answer my own question...

    I have a counter on my chart that ticks off the # of contracts remaining before the bar closes. Admittedly, I'm unable to watch every click of the thing, but I have yet to see evidence that TS' CVBs are not capped at the specified number. But I'll continue to watch...
     
    #49     Jan 31, 2007
  10. No, their bars aren't capped. They have been after my programmer to give them his program he created to fix TS's bars but he told them to sit and spin. They could do it they just don't see the need to spend the programming hours necessary.
     
    #50     Jan 31, 2007