They are the same, although this poster does try to act different, there are still many tells that give him away. eg. Both nicks put me on Block (when that feature still worked).
Unless they both show their trades, it would be nearly impossible to determine who's the "better trader". Basing that merely on $ or % change, while important, won't tell you the entire story, like how good his entries and exits were, or what kind of drawdowns he might have initially had that luckily turned around, etc.
Stop creeping, dude. Didn't you beg off already? Nobody asked for your (worthless) opinion... yet again?! Don't let us keep you from your one lots. There is only one trader in the comp. The other dude bailed in the first hour. I don't bail so I will see it through. I am going to let two vol-guys (and Baron) look at the book at the end of the comp. All the metrics will be provided. DD, Sharpe, etc. As fcking stated. Since you're so focused on my junk... join the party!
What about ET's self proclaimed best TA trader @wxytrader He drives a Lambo. Are you willing to challenge this new guy Poopy? Where is SML, he wanted to Rumble?