Got a PM from our friend Charlie Dow. I am respodoing here to show everyone what a kind person the Prof is, trying to shut someone up with threats. vital-analitixs vital-statistix psycho-analitx Bill Anyone reading the old threads can find out your name. If you don't see that what you are advocating is a load of shit then you are even more naive than I thought. Can you take 10K to 1M in 3 months? Once you can do that and it is not limited to one timeframe and it is not limited to just volume (or tick charts) and it is not limited to one symbol and it is not limited to size then you may have something to talk about. Until then I suggest you shut up with your condescending tone. Also, once you really discover "the secret of the markets", do you realise the implications of that? Your personal security? Because it would make the markets unstable and the government will want to shut you up, they cannot have an unstable market. The criminals will be after you because they won't want others to get your system. Foreign governments will be after you because they will want a piece of the pie. Don't worry, I leave you alone. After all we need more goats in this industry that I can take the money away from. And you just help them getting releaved from their heard earned cash a lot faster. Goodbye
Well I do not have first hand experience with it but know someone who recently attended a seminar. He told me the class was taught over the weekend and then was able to see live trading on Monday occurring in front of him. Now the part I would not have believed unless he told me was that every trade taken that day (I don't know if this was a fluke of being an exceptional day) was a winner and that 8 or 9 ES points were made. Now whether this person I know will ever get to this point is a different story. At least it provided some verification of truth that Charlie has a method that works well for him and backs up what he has been saying.
I don't know if this was a serious post or not but if I had just stepped into this thread and this was the first post I read I would think you might be a little off your rocker. What you are suggesting for verification of someones trading results and the results of someone trading the market really well are a little out in left field.
guys, this is really a dirty way of wasting ET space with useless uneducated guesses. i mean if someone came along with a method & i would be genuinely interested & OPEN in adding to my current one i would do the following: -> prove the method works, disprove it, or prove to myself it doesn't work for me (attention, this could hurt) at least after that process an opinion could be respected. but hey, maybe this is just too much common sense for most traders, so i'll leave it at that relaxed weekend, cosmic
So sweet. What about my comments? All are true. By the way I haven't attacked you personally, you have. Is that your behavior if you can't prove someone wrong or if someone showed that you are wrong?
Posting PMs shows a lot about you, too. Regardless of what is in the PMs. Can he take 10k to 1M in 3 months? Wherefore do you state such comments? Can you? Prove it to me. Does it say anything about the quality of that trader? No!
As stated . . . such a lovely person to hide in the net. I ask a question and it's a threat. I bet if I sneeze it will be read as a pass.
Personally guys I vote to end this. Poor Bill's thread got hijacked and I feel partially responsible. My only desire was to add to the thread not overwhelm it. This is the reason I changed the moniker in the first place. Have a wonderful weekend and go hang out with the family. Go prepare for the "Bird & Ball" later this week!
whatever i think about your methods, one thing is for sure---- you have quite the sense of humour ! i mean sincerely without a hint of sarcasm. surfer