Studying the following dividend case will prove you wrong, as having the dividends in the model is very important: http://www.elitetrader.com/et/index...es-of-estx50-atm-options-so-different.298090/ It was a very educational case also for me, I learnt much about the BIG impact of dividends on the Call and Put prices. As spindr0 correctly stated, and I cite him here, "dividends are priced into the options. It makes no sense to use a model that doesn't price the dividends", so it doesn't make to think otherwise; the markets work like they work, you have to follow the rules of the market. Using BlackScholesMerton with dividends is the mathematical correct way, and there are countless research papers on this, all verifyable by anyone with enough math skills.
It could be up to the writer... ;-) It is unclear what you want to demonstrate (or ask?) with your 2 calculation cases. Yes, both are used. So, then what is your question?