Oanda or IB?

Discussion in 'Forex Brokers' started by dtjohnson01, Jan 25, 2008.

  1. ssss

    ssss

    forestgril


    Dear ssss,

    The minimum amount for mini forex account with GFT is 500$. For a beginning, I would rather start with 250$, because I do not know my emotions during real play.

    Is there any reasonable other choice besides Oanda for such a small capital?
    #################

    http://www.gftforex.com/documents/processing_fees.pdf

    please read side one mini account minimum
    250$ for mini account by GFT or possible 700 pln

    effective januar 1 2008
    #################


    After that with suggest to this official document disscuss with
    GFT chat ....

    Best wish ....
     
    #81     Feb 11, 2008
  2. ssss

    ssss

    Mon, 11 Feb 2008 10:57 AM ( 1 hour 44 mins ago ) Text view
    HTML view
    Print view
    From "Rowland Turton" <rturton@gftuk.com> [Add]
    To SSSS




    Hi SSSS

    I understand that you have some questions relating to opening an account with GFT Global Markets.
    The minimum account opening balances are as follows.



    Mini Forex: US$500 or equivalent

    Standard Forex: US$2500 or equivalent

    Contract For Difference: US$2500 or equivalent

    ************************

    Answer of the author

    Please check your company side

    http://www.gftforex.com/documents/processing_fees.pdf

    please read side one mini account minimum
    250$ for mini account by GFT or possible 700 pln
    Effective 1 januar 2008 !

    ***************************************

    For another reader*s -

    1. Account manager(in case of MBT owner) knew not
    (in case of MBT public lies) what he says/wrote

    2.To author answered GFTforex U.K. ,not GFTforex USA

    To your knowledge competence of FSA U.K. incomparable lower as competence of SEC USA and lower as competence of
    CFTC (related to regulation forex based USA broker) .But better as in Swiss ,where Swiss forex market/broker are not regulated .

    Better offer account only in USA ,not in U.K .
    *************************************

    Summary -not to send to any broker any cent ,with exception ,this which was won by trader contest with
    entry without charge .

    Any suspect -exist alternative ,buy multiple bottle*s of good
    cognac . 250$ = approx 4 bottle of 0.7 litr Delamain Pal &DRy
    25 years .GR.CH. (Delamain is one company in the world ,which not make cognac with age lower as 25 years) and drink with friends

    Recently author won some money and would use prize money
    to this objective*s

    http://www.delamain-cognac.com/
     
    #82     Feb 11, 2008
  3. ssss,

    thank You for Your funny statement about cognac :)

    But I would rather start to be productive, because having fun with friends all the time is boring :)

    Indeed, probably the consultants are not well informed. I asked my GFT consultant to clarify, so I will know tomorrow.

    I think that a broker with a good position will not steal from small accounts, because every unhappy client on the forums makes them loose potential money from new naive clients.
     
    #83     Feb 11, 2008
  4. ssss, You've mentioned about "marketzar"

    can I open an account there without paying 50$ for the platform? I cannot find such a site.
     
    #84     Feb 11, 2008
  5. ssss

    ssss

    www.marketzar.com

    yes ,you can play small contest without entry charge 50$

    but first prize would only 300$ ,not 1500$ as in contest with entry.
     
    #85     Feb 12, 2008
  6. ssss

    ssss

    #86     Feb 12, 2008
  7. ssss,

    thank You very much for Your help.

    I wish You better and better trades all the time, good times with friends and cognac :) and long times of beatifull silence at most!

    ....By the way ;] You seem to be very well informed. The way You write makes You a little bit mysterious - like old master of trading ;D Could You, please, give any more clues about trading? Where to search? I am a beginner (trading demo consistently for half of a year), interested in Elliot wave theory, which seems to work well on forex with fibonacci analysis. I am a nanoelectronics phycist with scientifical approach and have also good c++ programming skills. I will try to develop my own system or implement a working one. I would always appreciate every clue to make my dreams come true.

    I know You "wasted" a lot of thime on this thread clearing out "banalities", but somehow I feel, that You really have a deep knowledge of the markets. If You wrote some clues here or to the PM... I would be grateful.

    Anyhow thank You very much again :)
     
    #87     Feb 12, 2008
  8. ssss

    ssss

    ....By the way ;] You seem to be very well informed. The way You write makes You a little bit mysterious - like old master of trading ;D Could You, please, give any more clues about trading? Where to search?

    1. No it is false .To be good from author point of view ,must win
    15-20 contests -with paper money -they have very good advantage ,that not taxed through germany law
    and with real money .
    To date it is not case -author have had operativ best result in USA ,Swiss ,Germany ,but exist lot of persons better as author .


    2. Could You, please, give any more clues about trading?


    No that can not help ,each person have different knowledge ,skill ,risk acceptance and different objective's

    Author not so good in trading to date and have not and interessed not to develop any kind of didactic skill

    you can try ask www.markdcook.com or www.turtletrader.com

    but all on your own responsibility .Author not support all ,what they say/wrote ...




    Author won by www.marketzar.com (milstar dec2006,feb 2007)
    through intense training
    4 days per week full day training 5-th day game .
    In year 2006,2007 was offered until 6-8 contest's
    per month .

    Sorry for author ,marketzar shutdown author after conflict with
    price money transfer ...

    I am a nanoelectronics phycist with scientifical approach and have also good c++ programming skills. I will try to develop my own system or implement a working one. I would always appreciate every clue to make my dreams come true

    ask www.rentec.com ,they need this kind of persons .
    see job offered .

    it is the best adress for trading skill for funds .Before fees
    70-80% per year(after fees 35-36%) last 18 years for great foreign capital
    (risk adjusted ,sharp ratio &) Medallion
    This fund is better as Buffet , Soros and all another famous name's


    Best wish .....

    http://www.turtletrader.com/trader-simons.html

    The advantage scientists bring into the game is less their mathematical or computational skills than their ability to think scientifically. They are less likely to accept an apparent winning strategy that might be a mere statistical fluke.
    Jim Simons President Renaissance Technologies
     
    #88     Feb 12, 2008
  9. I've seen www.rentec.com

    I have just started my PhD, I have my beloved girlfriend here and a child.

    And also they need outstanding programists and I think, that I'm merely good.

    But I plan to make consistently more than 500% in a year within 3 years, so the reward (150-250k USD a year) is not that important. Anyway I will think about trying to join them after I have my degree in nanoelectronics. It is more interesting than markets.
     
    #89     Feb 12, 2008
  10. #90     Feb 13, 2008