Oanda just another bucket shop

Discussion in 'Forex Brokers' started by MickMason, Apr 6, 2007.

  1. Sorry, IdealPro with Interactive Brokers.
     
    #101     May 5, 2007
  2. cstfx

    cstfx

    IB is one of the firms I use. It's cheap and efficient. My only complaint is on the crosses. For that I use HotSpotFx.

    (Disclaimer: I am in no way recommending either of these firms, they are just the 2 I use and am comfortable with. Many others will find that trading thru a Currenex platform is more efficient for the style of trading they prefer.)
     
    #102     May 5, 2007
  3. Yeah, with IB the crosses are replicated which reduces client leverage. I use HotSpotFXi as well.
     
    #103     May 5, 2007
  4. Do you trade spot with them cstfx?

    I've read their forex platform can be a bit 'quirky' and position keeping slightly obscure, is that your opinion too?

    I've just opened a master account with them but as clients haven't been tranferred on to it yet I haven't got full access hence the questions.

    Thanks

    Mick
     
    #104     May 5, 2007
  5. cstfx

    cstfx

    Yeah, I use them for spot and to leverage futures positions. Yes, the platform is quirky; they are late coming to the forex table, so to speak, and they are still trying to give us a respectable front end for trading. And yes, position reporting is something they have acknowledged and are still working on. Like I said someplace else on this forum, it ain't perfect. I think it is obvious their focus for the past few months is to try to get as stable a platform as possible (and that's debatable) to withstand the scrutiny of the public going into the IPO. Now that that is out of the way, hopefully they will beef up the programming staff, and maybe, give us a non-java based front end.

    Also, for my next birthday, I want to be 6 ft tall.
     
    #105     May 5, 2007
  6. IBj at IB mentioned they were working on the margin problems with crosses. I'll admit it is a hassle. I've been trading synthetic crosses in the futures markets, which is even less convenient (using excel to calculate dollar neutral futures positions).
     
    #106     May 5, 2007
  7. Thanks for the replies guys, as long as I know roughly what to expect!

    I can handle those issues as long as execution is good, connection problems would be a pain but hopefully they're sorting that one out.

    Margin requirements I don't think matter a great deal, 50:1 or 25:1, it's a bit academic really. Is that the margin problem you were talking about or is there another problem with margin or margin calls?

    Commission looks very cheap, .2 pip, or have I missed some hidden expenses somewhere?
     
    #107     May 6, 2007
  8. All this talk about IB.

    I don't know about you all, but when I try to figure these folks out, I get really confused with their web page.

    Also, now that they are going public, I think I would rather wait awhile before trading with them. :confused:
     
    #108     May 7, 2007
  9. Moe27

    Moe27

    i don't think ib follow the k.i.s.s. method, keep it simple stupid.
     
    #109     May 7, 2007
  10. Barrier to entry.
     
    #110     May 7, 2007