My nq price action method

Discussion in 'Journals' started by slugar, Sep 1, 2013.

  1. Redneck

    Redneck

    Trade plan (created for each trade)

    1.) Signal / entry
    2.) Initial Stop loss
    3.) Target / way of managing trade

    =====================

    1st trade

    1.) short on a retracement to the supply line / entry 3562.25
    2.) stop 3565.50
    3.) Exit when supply line is broken.


    Solid trade

    Question regarding 3.) above though – breach of the overall supply line…

    Or the near term supply line - made by the red bar w/ the wick (almost center of your first red circle)… and the next long red bar)

    Or a breach of the intermediate supply line - made after the 3 green bars (8:36 ish)

    I don’t know the PA that precedes the first red circle – but if you look there are a couple of things going on

    A DB – before price swings back up the to the over all supply line (8:41 ish)

    And.., once price swings back up and puts in the DT – there is essentially a range – encompassing the 2 DTs and the 2 DBs (8:30 - ~8:46 ish)

    Just something to be aware of as the session is unfolding


    Later.., at the bottom of the move down from the DT…, notice how price consolidated a bit (5 bars) at the bottom of the range I mentioned (8;51 - 8:55 ish) …, retraced to ~ the halfway point (50%) of the range.., then resumed down


    Additional sign of weakness





    2nd trade

    1.) short off of the steeper drawn supply line / short 3548
    2.) stop of 3551
    3.) exit when supply is broken.

    Price pulled back…, but never made it to the bottom of the range I mentioned above – close to the bottom.., but not to it (further sign of weakness)

    This move / area could also constitute as a DT entry (1 top just prior to 8:49... the 2nd just after 8:49)

    Good trade


    3rd trade

    1.) long on the retracement from the demand line and also a higher low / long 3526.75
    2.) stop at 3523
    3.) or when demand line is broken.


    This one I question a bit

    The demand line;

    Appears like you drew it off the body.., and not the wick/ tail

    Yet other lines – you’ve drawn off the wicks / tail

    I would respectfully suggest you pick one method and stick to it (wicks or bodies) – I use the wick / tail

    Another aspect I question – you went long into a range (9:45 to ~9:50) – had you considered that??

    Last aspect – I think the risk was a bit much for the conditions

    Bars 10:11 / 10:12 / 10:13 make HLs and a demand line (up move TL) – why not make a breach of that the stop and reduce your risk by almost 1/2


    4th trade

    1.) long from a higher low / long at 3535.75
    2,) stop at 3530
    3.) exited at the double top which was the 5th trade / or when demand line is broken.

    I question this trade also

    Higher low – from the low @ 10:08??

    If so.., what queued you in this was a HL

    I see price testing the top of the range formed @ (9:45 to ~9:50)

    I also see another range just above your entry @ 10:31 to 10:38

    My opinion (only) with all the weakness throughout – this trade is very risky – if I had gone long – the target would be top (test) of the 10:31 t- 10:38 range


    The stop for my long would have been 3551 (absolutely no room – it either works…, or fails and I’m out)


    last trade

    1.) short (DT I assume) / short at 3539.50
    2.) stop at 3542
    3.) exited on the trend line break around 1:30 / exit when supply line is broken

    Solid trade


    ===============

    General comments

    I like your clean charts (minimal lines) – makes it easy to focus on PA / trade signals

    RN
     
    #431     Apr 27, 2014
  2. Redneck

    Redneck


    Trading (vs learning) Always use the top down approach (learning use bottom up)

    Overall TF; create/ identify – the trend & channel

    Intermediate TF; also create / identify – the trend & channel…, AND also the S/R areas

    Where is price in each of those

    (recall the horizontal / vertical map)

    ===============

    Iow.., potentially price could fall a f’n long way....

    3 possible scenarios

    Buying steps in.., and drives price up

    Selling steps in…, and continues driving it down

    Possibly an attempt to make a new intraday zone as a reference

    (could be S.., or R.., just depending if price on top or the bottom of this zone)

    Be ready for any combination of these

    But no matter - keep your head down..., create your context... create a plan for each trade - trade each plan - move on

    ==================================


    Aside;

    This is not a prediction – just an observation…

    mkt has been ignoring pretty much all decent to good earnings this past week

    And Monday’s have a habit of being down days

    We never know.., but time will tell

    =======================


    If you want – create a channel of the overall…, and a channel / S&R areas of the intermediate – then post it...,

    We’ll have a look and see what we see

    RN
     
    #432     Apr 27, 2014
  3. slugar

    slugar

    4 hour
     
    #433     Apr 27, 2014
  4. Redneck

    Redneck

    The granularity on this chart stinks.., but it's free

    It has a 5 hr TF setting.., not 4

    To get the horizontal levels "close" - I switched to the 15 - as it's what I'm used to

    Then switched back to the 5 hr to mirror your chart as close as possible


    RN
     
    #434     Apr 27, 2014
  5. slugar

    slugar

    1 hour support and resistance horizontal
     
    #435     Apr 27, 2014
  6. slugar

    slugar

    2500 tick
     
    #436     Apr 27, 2014
  7. slugar

    slugar

    2500 with mid point
     
    #437     Apr 27, 2014
  8. Redneck

    Redneck

    What I'm about to say - may want bounce off Ammo (always more than one way to skin that cat)


    I identify S/R areas as zones (have an upper and lower limit) - drawn as horizontal channels

    Only time I'll use a single line is when price hits a level - and is immediately rejected (either up or down)

    Think a long tail/ wick..., or possibly even a solid bar

    ==================

    But typically I denote S&R as zones.., and draw them as horizontal channels

    RN
     
    #438     Apr 27, 2014
  9. Redneck

    Redneck

    That is a clean channel....

    Only question - does it go far enough back (capture enough of the intermediate PA)

    RN
     
    #439     Apr 27, 2014
  10. Redneck

    Redneck

    My thought - S&R zones are too big to be usable

    RN
     
    #440     Apr 27, 2014