Macd

Discussion in 'Technical Analysis' started by richk, Nov 8, 2002.

  1. Boomer

    Boomer

    I know that it is a great swing trading indicator, at least for my setup. Can some of the macd-daytraders go into their setups using it on an intraday basis?
     
    #11     Nov 29, 2002
  2. spieler

    spieler

    done above your post
     
    #12     Nov 29, 2002
  3. bhds

    bhds

    Whats ZeroLag MACD?

     
    #13     Nov 29, 2002
  4. onelot

    onelot

    What do you mean by oversituation? Is it an overextension type indication... is that what you mean?
     
    #14     Nov 29, 2002
  5. TG

    TG

    I have an intraday one min chart on my core trading stocks with MACD, RSI, and ADX (most important for me) as the technical indicators I use to verify my trading decisions. The chart tells me the story and the indicators aid in the process.
     
    #15     Nov 29, 2002
  6. spieler

    spieler

    oversituation means : overbougt / oversold

    In daytrading the more difficult is not to find signal it is to eliminate signals. It means a different approach.

    For example with MACD if you have a double signal it is far better like a divergence and a cross in the same time.
    sorry for the french language on the graph bellow but i'am french :)
     
    #16     Nov 30, 2002
  7. Nice chart spieler. IMO, there is no more powerful signal than the macd divergence.

    For those who are new to it, the term divergence used above is not in the same context as the in the name of the indicator. Moving average convergence divergence refers to the action of the averages that make up the indicator itself.

    Divergence as spieler et al are referring to is the action between price and the indicator. I saw a post that used convergence to describe the action of the price and the indicator. This is not correct. Price going down and indicator going up is considered a divergence between the two. Price going up and the indicator going down is considered a divergence between the two. Neither one represents a convergence.

    It's not about being right... it is about being accurate.
     
    #17     Nov 30, 2002
  8. onelot

    onelot

    ok, that's what i thought you meant...

    so basically you're defining overbought/oversold levels by the divergence between price and the MACD...

    have you found that to be consistent in all market conditions? choppy and trending?

    thanks
    onelot
     
    #18     Nov 30, 2002
  9. I've got the macd set at 12,26,9
    And to add to the misery, I have the 10 over 30 sma going also.
    You may think it's ma overkill
    But I am just trying to stay out of that casino they call Congestion
    And scalp in the Land of Safe Milk and Honey

    Anyway you boil it down, it all comes out to buy support and sell resistance. Only in my book, the best resistance to sell is that which has just recently been converted from Supportism.
     
    #19     Jan 8, 2003
  10. i use macd intra day (8,24 1 min) in conjunction with the tape, chart trend and open book.
     
    #20     Jan 8, 2003