MACD/Trendline Swing Trader

Discussion in 'Journals' started by retire45, Jan 26, 2008.

  1. Why do you use a MACD over a stochastics?..just wondering.
     
    #231     May 30, 2008
  2. I do consider stochastic in my reversal scan.. Super strong or Super weak stocks simply peg the stochastic and keep going.. NYSE stocks especially tend to trend strong.
     
    #232     May 30, 2008
  3. Missed another PCX run.. snooze you lose. You wonder for how long these things can keep going..
     
    #233     May 30, 2008
  4. See attached DOW hourly.. You see during that nasty drop the Stochastic got pegged in the lower ranges.. You had to give MACD the priority as a "SWING" trader.. an intraday trader probably could have traded the stochastic against the MACD but not for too long...

    What's the current read??? Seems MACD is topping but Stochastic has bottomed and along with us being at the swing low of yesterday a bounce is due but I think MACD wins in the end.. i.e. the next stochastic top a chance to short with stop above 12740 or so..
     
    #234     May 30, 2008
  5. epetrov

    epetrov

    Exactly on the point shown on your graph I wouldn't trade.
    The reason is that the pullbacks are too congetsed area, for a lot of bull and bears. Some people are willing to push the price higher, but another people (BO traders) are pushing the price down. There are also too many stops, and many people are going to switch their opinions.
    So this is a risky place. There is not accondance with the traders which way the price will go.:confused:
     
    #235     May 30, 2008
  6. 9999

    9999

    As long as the price respects the trendline, I'd remain long.
    That's how I see it.
    Very nice journal BTW, congrats.
     
    #236     May 30, 2008
  7. epetrov

    epetrov

    BO traders are waiting for your skin.
     
    #237     May 30, 2008
  8. For sure a battle here... 12640 key..

    Triggered into CLR 64.11
    Can't click on HES may wait for today's high to be taken out on Monday..
     
    #238     May 30, 2008
  9. Borderline vile markets.. to wait till last 10 minutes to reveal their cards... or did they? All that nothing movement got me into some boredom trades.. Short DRYS and LFG.. The challenge of trading..

    A steady Week.. only 1 error from an entry standpoint (STP).. and 1 on exit (FINL). I'll accept them in exchange for a gook week.. Off to the day job.
     
    #239     May 30, 2008
  10. Good Weekend..
     
    #240     May 30, 2008