Learning to read Price Action with P&F Charting

Discussion in 'Strategy Building' started by HolyGrail, Mar 22, 2008.

  1. HooLee

    HooLee

    My MOS trade really went south, thanks everyone who offered their opinions.

    Try again, how about this one: XOM

    It responds to today's crude inventories report with a breakout, it will be stronger if takes out 96.
     
    • xom.png
      File size:
      8.7 KB
      Views:
      151
    #841     May 21, 2008
  2. HooLee

    HooLee

  3. hayman

    hayman

    I apologize in advance if this has been mentioned already (it may have), but in the spirit of sharing information on P&F, here are 4 great resources:

    1) Book by Thomas J. Dorsey, "Point and Figure Charting", 3rd edition. I liked this book a lot, and would have loved it, had it not been for the author promoting his web (paid) services a bit too much.

    2) Book by Jeremy du Plessis, "The Definitive Guide to Point and Figure". Awesome book, with great color charts. If interested, the cheapest price around for it is on Buy.com (much cheaper than Amazon.com).

    3) On Tom Dorsey's Website (www.dorseywright.com), there is a link for "FREE PNF Online Lessons". This is free, and a
    great review of PnF. By the way, these lessons also come on a CD, that comes with Dorsey's book above.

    4) This thread is great. HolyGrail's summary document is great, and needs to be read several times, to catch all the subtleties. The BEST comment in this treatise, IMO, is the trading avoidance strategy during chop markets (looking for double signals is an AWESOME strategy - it will increase winning % tremendously, and cut down on # of superfluous trades.

    As far as trading environment is concerned (for short-term day traders), I love using the IB data feed, with Quote Tracker. It is a FREE data solution, and I find it to be extremely adequate. I trade ES intra-day, and am still using IB's native Trader Workstation for trades (I need to look around for a better interface). One thing that Quote Tracker lacks is the automated drawing of trend lines. I use Wealth-Lab Developer (now owned by Fidelity - www.wealth-lab.com) for this purpose. I use an old V3.01 version of this S/W, and there is a FREE plug-in for this that supports PnF, which automatically draws Bullish Support and Bearish Resistance trend lines for you, which I find extremely useful. The charts for WL and QT aren't exactly the same (different implementations), but they are close. By the way, WL's native IB plug-in no longer works, but WL supports a Quote Tracker interface. So, my data flow is IB -> QT -> WL, and this works great, without any performance degradation, on a single CPU (of course, QT also supports communication with IB from a different machine as well).

    Thanks again to HolyGrail for getting me involved in PnF. I've turned off all my indicators, and just watch Supply and Demand fight it out during the course of the day.....makes a lof of sense, and certainly makes life simpler.
     
    #843     May 21, 2008
  4. agreed.with above.
    the consecutive signals/holygrail
    that rule is great..it certainly keeps you out of the toxic waste !!!!
     
    #844     May 21, 2008
  5. agreed.with above.
    the consecutive signals/holygrail
    that rule is great..it certainly keeps you out of the toxic waste !!!!
     
    #845     May 21, 2008
  6. agreed.with above.
    the consecutive signals/holygrail
    that rule is great..it certainly keeps you out of the toxic waste !!!!
     
    #846     May 21, 2008
  7. Nothing wrong with the stock. Might be a little something wrong with the r/r at this level. Theoretically you would have to place your stop at 87.00.

    Edit: well maybe not. The horizontal projection is at 120, so actually it looks pretty damn good.
     
    #847     May 21, 2008
  8. HooLee

    HooLee

    Thank you!

    Disappointed by the price action in the afternoon, here is the plan now: will add at 90/91, stop set to 87.
     
    #848     May 21, 2008
  9. Because the weather has been too bad to work the last 2 days, I spent a lot of time going over charts. Altho I have found lots of good buy and sell signals, I realize there is no way I can go thru all the charts I need, to catch all the good signals so I can decide the best stocks to buy in a timely fashion.
    Even using the Stockcharts scans and looking at the ones that have already given a signal takes an exorbitant amount of time. (and no, I'm not looking for something to just fall in my lap with no work), but I spent all day today and barely scratched the surface doing it manually.

    After drawing a chart with some of my picks and comparing them to different markets, indices, I started to recognize something similiar to the charts "TheRumpledOne" has posted on jjrvat's thread, I got to wondering if it was possible or if someone has developed scans and filters that would take some of the time out of searching thru charts.

    Disregard the actual stocks, markets compared to and results, as some have been just put in erroneoulsy and are probably comparing to the wrong markets



    STOCK------$SPX -----$INDU-------$NYA ---------SECTOR---------BP%

    CGN-----------^ ----------^-------------^ -------------^ --------- x%
    DVN------------Y-----------Y--------------^-------------Y ---------- x%
    FCS------------^----------^--------------^-------------^----------x%
    OMX-----------^----------^--------------^--------------^-----------x%
    TKS------------^----------^--------------^--------------^-----------x%
    CMCSK--------^----------^--------------^--------------^-----------x%
    FORR----------^----------^--------------^--------------^-----------x%
    MCCC---------^-----------^-------------^--------------^------------x%
    MRTN----------^-----------^-------------^--------------^------------x%
    PACR----------^-----------^-------------^--------------^------------x%
    VRGY----------^-----------^-------------^---------------^-----------x%

    Its pretty crude but I was wondering what it would take to set up a scan/ filters to do this searching a little quicker than checking each one manually. or if Bullseye Broker, InvestorRT or Dorsey Wright already have this capability?
     
    #849     May 22, 2008
  10. the bottom part of this is what I was thinking of, with different market comparisons instead of MA's.
     
    #850     May 22, 2008