Ask him anything about his system and he disappears. Well, he'll come back in 18 hours, suitably aggrieved.
I responded in under 20 minutes for your first question and this one in under like 30 minutes. Yes, you beat me some of your responses are in under 15 minutes and sometimes under 3. Fully admit you win in replying faster, you got me.
So zero color into your entry criteria and your risk management is risk management. Got it. I can see why you were so hesitant on opening a journal. You literally have nothing to offer. I don't think you're keeping it close to the vest... I think you're punting visually off charts. I believe you're 100% discretionary, but not in a good way as in deep knowledge based upon ed and experience.
LOL. Yes, if he says he never met a long term profitable day trader of index futures I believe him. It's of no consequence to me either way, but interesting nonetheless. It was surprising to me that the number was zero, though. Generally, I don't think institutional or professional traders are directionally day trading indexes off charts.
Of course most of them aren't. Thats clear just by talking or trading with them even loosely. They are good at what they specialize in or at the very least for some of them good at making connections. Thing is poopy doesn't even think it's possible at all. I am completely shocked at the amount of misinformation regarding d1 trading on this forum. EliteInvestor would be a much more appropriate name. Not even joking.
Ok well my entry criteria is 100% objective. My risk management while not a fixed value is also 100% objective. The only discretionary thing is I don't always take every setup due to the filter. If you're confident that information is incorrect and that I am just punting. That's excellent, nice analysis skills.
HTF would you know anything about "D1 misinformation"? 70% D1: https://www.elitetrader.com/et/threads/dests-everything-journal.332136/page-11#post-4859112 That was not my best day in March, 2019.