Iterative Refinement

Discussion in 'Journals' started by Spydertrader, Jan 3, 2008.

  1. Neoxx

    Neoxx

    It's great that so many people are posting their charts... creates a really rich debriefing resource.

    Here's my not-yet-debriefed version (repost from Technical Strategy)...
     
    #10191     Dec 12, 2008
  2. sscott

    sscott

    I saw it as the the completion of the non-dominant traverse pt2 to pt3 of the downtrend channel from yesterday. Is that correct?
     
    #10192     Dec 12, 2008
  3. Nice ! :)
     
    #10193     Dec 12, 2008
  4. I thought we hadn’t finished yesterday's traverse down and therefore I was anticipating pt.2 and 3 to form today. At 11:05 I thought FTT will BO what looked to me like FF, I failed to notice that Volume at BO was decreasing – a sign to fan out and not a BO. Looks like I made an error at the EOD assessment.
    I need to debrief some more.
     
    #10194     Dec 12, 2008
  5. I see what you are saying Spyder. My rendition of the day turned out to be very similar to ehorn’s (who else, we’re chart pals) and the gman (Don’t shoot g-man! – Machine Gun Kelly http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machine_Gun_Kelly Hopefully you don’t look like this guy guava.) but you, I would deduce (hopefully not adduce), opt for something more along the lines of the Neoxx chart.

    My faulty reasoning had the 15:35 bar as a combo P3 validation/real deal peak volume signal followed by a JW Type I and then an up OB. Interestingly we all end up in the same place with an incomplete second up traverse in ‘non-dom’ at EOD – the old fortuitous cancellation of errors.

    Having once again bared my soul and suffered the horrific consequences, could you possibly answer two tiny questions? Are those tapes I annotated “fat tapes”? When one has the less common peak volume signal is the peak volume bar itself always the ‘change’ bar (the new P1) or can something like I constructed happen as well?

    TIA

    lj
     
    #10195     Dec 12, 2008
  6. ehorn

    ehorn

    Alas, I fear I may be stuck in my bad habit of jumping fractals... You know that "Missing a critical component" thing.

    Keeping on the right fractal continues to be quite a challenge for me.

    P.S. Neo's chart get my vote for the closest to reality :D
     
    #10196     Dec 12, 2008
  7. ES
     
    #10197     Dec 12, 2008
  8. For me as well. I have found however, that by trading the tape fractal I don't have to worry about jumping up a fractal. :D
     
    #10198     Dec 12, 2008
  9. Neoxx

    Neoxx

    You must have noticed by now that reality's not my forte. :D
     
    #10199     Dec 12, 2008
  10. ehorn

    ehorn

    Nicely Done treeline. That is the Real PT2. (IMO)

    I missed the turn and without my GPS handy I was not seeing the sequences play out today (or the red barn!) :D

    Your TL's looks like a clockwork to me. Lets see if this FF gets us out of that Channel TL for a new Channel PT2 (this time) :)
     
    #10200     Dec 12, 2008