Is there anyone here who has a consistently profitable automated trading system?

Discussion in 'Automated Trading' started by Blitzjoker, Jul 20, 2023.

  1. Overnight

    Overnight

    And you've been doing this for how long? Good grief man, know the instruments you trade, haha.

    And here's a pro-tip. If you look at the T&S, you'll see your piddly 60-lot orders, while adding liquidity, aren't moving the market one iota. 60-lots gets sucked up in an instant and the charts will not blink. Think of the Hungry-Hungry Hippos game. You're just a little white ball in a sea of hippos.
     
    #131     Aug 17, 2023
  2. toucan

    toucan

    sorry... i was wrong and you are right about 10 micros make up 1 mini... however, when you bring up an emini, it shows the actual number of contracts offerred and trades.
    thanks

    toucan
     
    #132     Aug 17, 2023
  3. toucan

    toucan


    i didn't know retail traders had access to the full sized contract.. thought only emini and micros were traded now.

    thanks
    toucan
     
    #133     Aug 17, 2023
  4. rb7

    rb7

    OMG, how can you trade the ES without knowing this basic thing???
    Knowing the product that you're trading is like basic 101...
     
    #134     Aug 17, 2023
    virtusa likes this.
  5. LOL "piddly", aren't you the spicy one... I'm glad to hear we're not moving the market. Even being wrong on my (mis)understanding of the Bid/Ask Size (I do come from a stock trading background before starting futures last year), all I really care about related to this topic is whether or not us placing simultaneous market orders for ~600 contracts does or does not move the market. I have assumed, based just on my (mis)understanding of the Bid/Ask Size, that the answer is no.

    As we have assumed up to this point that we're nowhere near moving the price one tick when placing 500-600 contract market orders (broken up but relatively simultaneously), when you are feeling less curmudgeonly, I'd love your "pro-tip" on the best practice to calculate/estimate what size market order WOULD move the price. It has not been on our radar up until now, but it may need to be. Thanks in advance.
     
    #135     Aug 17, 2023
  6. I guess I'll be saying this 50 different ways, but at our volume orderbook depth had not been on our radar because it hasn't needed to be. That being said, coming from a stock world where Size is in 100 share lots, I assumed Futures was displayed the same. Happy to admit I've been wrong on that, but doesn't change our trading results or strategy by even one line of code.
     
    #136     Aug 17, 2023
  7. virtusa

    virtusa

    If new members register on ET, we need a short time to understand in which category they really play. For me he just joined the category of the majority. I don't envy him.
     
    #137     Aug 17, 2023
  8. @NoahA I owe you a ginormous apology, you were 100% correct, and I was 100% wrong. It doesn't change anything we're doing on our end, But it DOES put on our radar we need to have a much better understanding of E-Mini depth/liquidity. So thank you for that, and apologies once again.
     
    #138     Aug 17, 2023
    Laissez Faire, TraderDaveUK and NoahA like this.
  9. NoahA

    NoahA

    Yes, for futures, you don't multiply by 100, and I think my chart shows this is the case since the volume on those 1 second bars is a couple of hundred contracts traded, and yet, price moves a few ticks.

    You're welcome to bring me on board as a consultant! :) I'm really good at finding problems and since I've been failing at this trading thing for so long, you almost need a contrarian on the team... LOL

    As for moving the market, I think it depends on the definition. You absolutely can move the market 1 or 2 ticks with an order of 50 or 100 contracts, depending on the time of day, but this likely does not move the direction. The way I see it is that if most traders want to buy, but if you get in their way and they can't get their price, they might not continue to buy and hence push the price up. So at what point does someone with their orders interfere with where the market was headed? On a small enough time scale, I'm sure you can make a difference, but on a day where we rally for hours, I doubt a few hundred contracts that front run buying algos from major firms would disappear and not buy themselves.
     
    #139     Aug 17, 2023
    chris.page likes this.
  10. NoahA

    NoahA

    No need to apologize. You weren't in anyway rude, you just stated your understanding which makes total sense. I've been at this futures trading business for so long that I've learned a million different things and nuances, down to studying micro structure, but I just haven't found a profitable way to trade it yet! LOL

    Glad I was able to help.
     
    #140     Aug 17, 2023
    Laissez Faire and TraderDaveUK like this.