Is it must be more complicated then that ??

I have nothing to teach a member in ET from 2007
With 8440 post..
It should be the other way..
But I pass the opertuinity any way..
Cheers.

 

There is such thing?

 

What makes you say that?
New insights arrive on ET from everywhere and every skill level.
I've set up "Cumulative Delta Bars - Volume" studies on my charts twice over time. Somebody uses them or they wouldn't be an option I'd imagine. You say that you're studying them. What specific questions do you have related to trading with them to make money? Sometimes posting a chart to make your case can sharpen the focus of discussion.

You may be on to something that just needs a little elbow-grease to sort it out.
1) What would comprise a Cumulative Delta Bars - Volume Setup, Leob?

https://www.sierrachart.com/index.p...hp&ID=292&Name=Cumulative_Delta_Bars_-_Volume

 

Answers are sometimes quick and (way to) sharp...
Please feel free to elaborate and post more detailed information.
Like myself, a lot of members will appreciate it.
Best!

 

Of course it is.
The question you should be asking is why was this approach not rejected out of hand by yourself? It is as if you are playing around with elementary stuff, and not doing the things that will get you beyond it.

In order to get somewhere you will need to have a test criteria to evaluate all the "new and cool ideas" you come up with. Otherwise you will spend too much time messing around with bad or mediocre stuff. Sure you seem "busy", but you will not make any meaningful progress.

You might end up with a 1000 or 2000 posts and still be talking about "easy money".

 

.

Or I rude or you naive or this is culture difference..
Any way..
I don't use this volume delta indicator of sierra I use this https://www.sierrachart.com/index.php?page=doc/StudiesReference.php&ID=315&Name=Up_Down_Volume_Ratio

 

It is I who is naive. Thanks for the info on UDVR.

 

Have you any opinions / ideas on this one?
Up/Down Volume Difference Bars (UDVDB)
https://www.sierrachart.com/index.p...hp&ID=454&Name=Up_Down_Volume_Difference_Bars

 

can you tell us what is the TP and SL ??, when i try to simulate this i just realize that i dont have TP and SL setup

 

Actually my intention was to send this..
https://www.sierrachart.com/index.php?page=doc/StudiesReference.php&ID=315&Name=Up_Down_Volume_Ratio